Last Update 15:40
Saturday, 20 July 2019

If the West wants to fight terror, it should support Egypt, not defame it

Galal Nassar , Wednesday 11 Nov 2015
Views: 3648
Views: 3648

Commenting on the Russian plane crash in Sinai, which claimed 224 lives on 31 October, the chairman of the special investigation committee said on Saturday that the investigation is underway and that nothing has been ruled out.

This brief comment is, so far, the most authoritative statement made by the investigation team, which includes representatives of five countries: Egypt, Russia, France, Germany and Ireland.

But Western intelligence services and media have drawn their own conclusions, claiming that the crash was due to an act of terror. London and Washington have been quite emphatic on this point, despite the fact that their intelligence services have declined to cooperate with Egypt every step of the way.

To date, no information has been shared by either the US or UK intelligence services. No conclusive information or physical evidence has been forthcoming, only premature conclusions.

Egypt hasn’t ruled out or given support to any possible scenario of the events leading to the tragedy. Neither President Abdel-Fattah Al-Sisi nor Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry have confirmed or denied media speculation. But the Egyptian public in general knows that if a terrorist act is indeed the cause, then we are the victims as well.

Egypt has been fighting a war on terror for the past few years, without the least offer of assistance of the powers that now speak so volubly about our shortcomings and mishaps. Thinly veiled ill will has permeated the premature speculation of Western powers, primarily the US and the UK, which now claim to have information about a terrorist act but decline to share that information with the fact-finding committee in charge of the investigation.

After the 9/11 attacks, the consensus in the international community was that all countries should stand together in the fight against terror. So the UN Security Council, on 28 September 2001, issued Resolution 1373 instructing all member states to provide all possible logistical and intelligence help in the war on terror.

In this case, however, neither the UK nor the US have done this, which puts them in flagrant violation of the abovementioned UN Security Council resolution, and yet they keep insinuating that the crash was Egypt’s fault.

There is a systematic campaign by the UK and US media against Egypt. This campaign is bolstered by other measures for escalation, including the evacuation of nationals, the suspension of flights and the cancellation of reservations.

Fabricated tales are now all over the Western media: tales of planes that come under missile fire; tales of employees who take bribes to skirt security procedures, etc.

Editorials are published that assault Egypt and badmouth its politics, mainly in connection with the ouster of the Muslim Brotherhood following the 30 June 2013 revolution. As usual, The Washington Post and The New York Times have led the charge.

None of these attacks have anything to do with the Russian plane tragedy. The loss of life in Sinai is just an excuse to put Egypt in its place and punish it for ousting the Muslim Brotherhood, thus depriving the West of the political ally on which it had laid so much hope.

In Washington, London and Berlin, politicians had dreamed of political Islam running the region under Western auspices, pacifying its people with the help of Iran, Turkey and Israel.

The 30 June Revolution changed all that, upsetting Western planners and robbing them of the will and ability to recognise the true wishes of the people who live in this region.

Some 30 million people took to the streets of Egypt on 30 June 2013 to say no to the Muslim Brotherhood, and all the political intrigues in the world cannot change that. But Egypt wasn’t forgiven for this act of audacity in the backrooms of Western politics, its punishment is far from complete.

The Muslim Brotherhood was aided and abetted by Western politicians. Its leaders were received with pomp and listened to with compassion. One day in the future, the Brotherhood and its friends dream, something will happen in Egypt that puts the Islamists back in the saddle, to the satisfaction of their Western allies.

But Egypt is standing fast. It is defeating Muslim Brotherhood-inspired terror, and it is pushing through with its roadmap. It is now electing a new parliament, and even with the low turnout, this is still an accomplishment worthy of praise.

Still, the Muslim Brotherhood and the Western capitals that support it are doing their best to undermine Egypt, wreck its economy, destroy its tourism and generate the discontent they hope will bring down its government and bring it back under Muslim Brotherhood rule.

We know we have problems. We know we have corruption and unemployment, human rights abuses and poor education, health issues and transportation failures. We don’t need The Washington Post to tell us that. We don’t need The Guardian to list our ailments.

But we could have used some help. Instead of haranguing us about deposing the extremists from power, Western capitals could have acted in good faith, sharing information about terror, for example, or helping train our airport security teams and our anti-terror squads.

Centuries ago, the West had its own revolutions, and managed for the most part to separate church and state. Why do they think that we cannot do the same? Why do they hold us to ridicule, rather than show respect?

Fabricated tales now circulate, aiming to undermine tourism and deal a body blow to our economy. Instead of providing assistance to a nation that is determined to fight terror and extremism in all their forms, defamation campaigns are being waged against us.

Egypt will continue to fight terror, regardless of the price. We are fighting the same terror that struck the US in September 2001, CharlieHebdo in France in January 2015, and Sousse in Tunisia in June 2015. Our country has six million people working in tourism, so if terrorists target visitors to our country, the world should help, not gloat.

The results of the ongoing investigation are still pending, but the last thing we need is to be lectured by those who do not, or will not, help.

This is a terrible tragedy, regardless of its causes. And it is a tragedy that has brought our nation together in grief and concern. Today, the government’s supporters and its critics stand united. We are willing to criticise our appointed and elected officials, but will not undermine the interests of the nation as a whole.

Meanwhile, we are aware that our political accomplishments are annoying to some people in the West. We are aware that our success in electing a new government is not sitting well with our detractors, especially those who befriended the Muslim Brotherhood.

We understand that our attempt to boost the abilities of the Armed Forces, and to wrest our armaments from Washington’s control, has alienated some people.

We can see how our success in finding new energy sources upsets the Muslim Brotherhood and its friends, who still dream of a glorious return to power.

We know that our rapprochement with Russia has surprised many who still have bitter memories of Soviet-Egyptian cooperation in the 1960s and 1970s.

But none of this justifies the rabid campaigns against us. None of this justifies gloating over a tragedy, the exact cause of which is still under investigation.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

15-11-2015 12:57pm
The "author" should be ashamed to pen such deliberately misleading paranoid drivel. These nut case conspiracy mongers come close to peddling hate speech, and are in real danger of causing serious harm to Egypt's long-term recovery. There is only so much abuse the West (providers of most of Egypt's tourism, foreign currency, military & economic aid and trade - so much for NOT helping, eh?) will take before turning away and leaving her to fast-dwindling friends in the Gulf and Russia. Ah, no - the Russians have already turned away........
Comment's Title

The Canadian Googster
12-11-2015 10:28pm
Yes, but...
The first and third comments issued so far on this article make sence to me. However, the author's point on 'Resolution 1373 instructing all member states to provide all possible logistical and intelligence help in the war on terror' is a valid point that can't be left aside.
Comment's Title

Sam Enslow
11-11-2015 03:44pm
I must add that essays like this tarnish the reputation of Egypt far more than the deaths of 224 individuals, including women and children. Egypt once again cries for itself. It notes the efficiency of returning bodies to Russia but show little remorse that visitors to its beaches were killed. All concern by Egypt seems to be it not be blamed for this event or lose money because of it. The true victims have been forgotten. Egypt seems, once again, more concerned by its image than in protecting its guests and taking steps to see such a horror doesn't happen again. I am pleased to see that authorities are starting to work with others to improve security, but the real test will be that reforms continue once international experts leave.
Comment's Title

11-11-2015 03:10pm
The Evil WEST …
It is one thing when an illiterate man on the street blames the West for all Egypt’s ills; it’s another when an intellect spews the same rhetoric. How would someone so proficient in English, capable of reading world media and policies make a statement such as “In Washington, London and Berlin, politicians had dreamed of political Islam running the region under Western auspices”! Unless such an intellect is a devout loyalist of the Ruling Army Regime that in so far has been successful in alienating the world through backward policies and amateurish PR! What so many failed to grasp, despite their intellect, is that the West denounces Political Islam in every form; however their tolerance to MB leaders is not driven by support for their ideology but by respect for their fair election by the Egyptian people. Many confuse the legitimacy of their fair election with the legitimacy of their ideology, on the contrary, it is in spite of!
Comment's Title

Ahmed Mansour Badr
11-11-2015 01:03pm
Take a break
It is certainly hard to accept but it is nevertheless true: The West just does not care enough about Egypt to make up stories, run campaigns, or plot any other vicious attack on our country. It is, however, concerned about the welfare of its citizens. This care includes making sure they can spend safe and joyful holidays, for example in Sharm. It also implies to welcome democratically elected Egyptian presidents, never mind from which part of society they hail from. For the same reason, Egypt is not able to "annoy" the West by pursuing its political goals though it does annoy the whole world if it is not able to ensure the safety of its guests. The attack on the white desert tourists, the poor Croation engineer and now 224 dead Russians testify to the incapability of our government to provide minimum standards. The world surely supports Egypt if help is accepted. However, acceptance also means to appropriately respond to justified criticism of unjustifiable government failures.
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.