Last Update 21:41
Sunday, 21 July 2019

Egypt re-assesses anti-militant tactics as Sinai militants change strategies

IS cells have been reported in Sinai, informed sources say

Ahmed Eleiba, Friday 5 Sep 2014
Egyptian troops in Sinai (Photo: Reuters)
Views: 3478
Views: 3478

Videos of the execution of young Egyptian men accused of spying for Israel, and mounting speculation about the appearance of Islamic State (IS) cells in Sinai and Upper Egypt point to a new wave of militant-related developments in Egypt.

On Tuesday, 11 security personnel were killed in North Sinai when their armoured vehicle hit an explosive device planted on the road between Sheikh Zuweid and Rafah. Four other security personnel were injured.

The current situation is too complex to be reduced to a handful of images, however gruesome. Security forces continue to record successes in the battle against terror, the latest being the killing of Fayez Abou Shita, and the successful raid on a terrorist den.

Egyptian intelligence agencies have obtained important information from such raids, including computers that have provided invaluable insight into the militant operations.

Security agencies had estimated the number of militants in Sinai at around 8,000. If that figure was correct, then following the elimination or capture of militant elements, it is unlikely that more than 500 remain at large.

General Mohamed Rashad, a former deputy director of the General Intelligence Services, warns against taking such figures seriously, “regardless of how widely circulated they are.” The situation on the ground, he says, is changing at an ever-accelerating speed. One of the more significant shifts is that many Egyptians who travelled to Syria during the Muslim Brotherhood’s rule to take part in the fighting there have now returned home.

Sinai, says Rashad, remains the most worrying terror hotbed, not least because “it is adjacent to Gaza, which is also major tributary for the export of extremism,” and the local terrain offers many places to hide. Nor can it be denied that there are some in the peninsula who are happy to defy the state.

Complaints are regularly voiced that the government is only present in Sinai when it carries out military operations. Others in the massively underdeveloped Sinai rely for their livelihoods on the conflict, or else are reportedly paid by foreign groups that seek to foment chaos in Egypt.

Militant organisations continue to target security forces in the Sinai, a fact often overlooked in international reports that focus exclusively on the rights of civilians. And the number of these groups is growing. The rumoured presence of IS cells in Egypt have proved to have a basis in fact. A military operation is currently in progress to target these cells in the Jebel Al-Hilal area. According to military sources, the initial purge will be followed by a combing operation that is expected to take some time.

The amount of time needed would be less, say sources, if there was greater international cooperation.

Washington’s foot-dragging on the issue has surprised many observers. It is, says one commentator, “a thorn in the side of Egyptian-US bilateral relations.”

Egyptian officials are increasingly exasperated with what they see as backtracking by the US. There have been delays in supplying equipment and providing maintenance for three Apache fighters, as well as the suspended delivery of 10 more aircraft that were the subject of an agreement signed when Mohamed Morsi was president.

General Rashad points to another complicating factor in the equation — a major shift in Israel’s strategy. The Israeli government is moving away from confronting the Palestinian resistance and towards tackling new groups that it believes constitute a real existential threat.

“We need to consider the role the US is playing in this shift,” says Rashad. “Washington is clearly very worried. It has been estimated that emerging militant groups will pose a significant threat to Israel by 2020.”

Rashad believes it may take longer for such “non-state organisations to create parallel entities” but nonetheless warns that a full-scale war against them in the Levant may be necessary by 2026.

Growing awareness in Washington of regional terror threats may pave the way for closer cooperation. US Secretary of State John Kerry has already told Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry that Egypt will soon receive the delayed military equipment.

That message was followed by the arrival in Cairo of Senator Howard “Buck” McKeon, chairman of the House of Representatives Armed Services Committee. The sole purpose of his visit was to discuss ways to combat the new wave of terrorism with Egyptian officials.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

Sam Ensslow
06-09-2014 03:35pm
Not Military/Police Fight
While it is necessary to use police and military forces to end violence, it is quite possible that their actions will increase, rather the lessen, the number of radical terrorists. Every error made by these forces will enhance in the people's minds the idea that the radicals are right - or right in part. Two other forces must be in play. First the mosque is the center of community life and must serve as a weapon against the radicals. Then there must be the economic development of the area in ways the people can see now. The government is not trusted and grand promises will not be believed with good reason.
Comment's Title

06-09-2014 08:14am
Secure Sinai with properity
Sinai has been neglected for too long. It has excellent potential for farming. It was tragic to have stopped the irrigation canal just before the olive harvest. Imagine if the people of Sinai could have harvested their crops and had a factory for high quality olive oil; soon they would be exporting to the world. This and many other ventures is what secures a region, not the army showing up when it is a fight to flush out terrorists. Sinai needs to be strong for Sinai and for Egypt.
Comment's Title

06-09-2014 04:43am
President Sisi has been a life saver for the region, if not the world.
He balances things for the complete incompetence of both Obama and Cameron. Two slow learners whose ineptitude has given life to wide spread terrorism.... And death to thousands of communities in the region. Who thought Bush Jr will be regarded not so bad in relation to the present clowns.
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.