Last Update 0:58
Wednesday, 22 May 2019

Islamist militants in Sinai rely on sophisticated networks of support, military experts say

Ahram Online spoke to two military experts on implications of Wednesday's of IS group terrorist attack on the Egyptian army in North Sinai on Wednesday

Ahmed Eleiba , Thursday 2 Jul 2015
Sinai-Gaza border
Egyptian army tank is seen as members of Palestinian security forces loyal to Hamas patrol the border area of southern Gaza Strip with Egypt, 1 July 2015 (Photo: Reuters)
Share/Bookmark
Views: 3840
Share/Bookmark
Views: 3840

Major General Hisham El-Halaby who teaches at the National Defence College of the Nasser Military academy- told Ahram Online that the initial number of militants who attacked the army in North Sinai earlier in the day was around 70.

"Those 70 who attacked the forces in Sheikh Zuweid represented the first wave of attackers. The total number of attackers throughout the day might exceed 300 elements or even more. This is a new technique that the militants have been using in their operations," El-Halaby explained.

However, El-Halaby says that there were gaps in the military’s preparedness, which were capitalised on by the militants who receive instructions from foreign intelligence agencies.

He believes that the perpetrators — whom he described as highly organized and trained — sought to deliver several messages through this attack, whether in terms of its timing or organization, or the type of deployment of the elements that implemented it.

“The militants attempted to control new territories around their current strongholds in the areas of Sheikh Zuweid and Rafah  — just as their sister groups have been doing in Iraq and Libya — in order to begin to expand west towards the Suez Canal areas.

"This plan failed," said El-Halaby.

Within security institutions — including the military — El-Halaby said there is a belief that the militant operation was planned by foreign intelligence agencies.

“We are facing intelligence bodies that chose the timing, prepared the attack and the elements that executed it, seeking to confront the Egyptian state and military."

El-Halaby reasoned that the weapons used in Wednesday’s attack are usually owned by armies, not other armed groups operating in the Nile Valley or Delta region.

El-Halaby explained that anti-aircraft  and C4 explosives used on Wednesday by the IS group are “ten times powerful than TNT explosives,” which are used elsewhere in Egypt by other Islamist militants.

El-Halaby said he also believes some Sinai Bedouins lend support to the militants by selling them with “modern and expensive vehicles” that “most probably have legal registration.”

“Some rights groups, whose members are above suspicion, provide a legal cover for transactions that Islamists need completed to access money to spend on operations, he claimed.

On the ability of authorities to gather intelligence, El-Halaby believes it is a difficult task to fulfill in such "a complex environment.”

“Militants adopt a counter-tactic of spreading false information, but unfortunately we have to admit there is a shortage in information that we or nobody else can overcome.”

“For instance, some sites for  weapons storage have not been discovered yet. Also some tunnels are still functioning efficiently and these allow elements who are based in the Gaza Strip to pass through them. One of them was discovered in the past few days, and most probably it was used in this operation.”

Meanwhile, Major General Talaat Moussa, former head of Egypt’s military intelligence, concurred Ahram Online that some Bedouins support hundreds of domestic and foreign Islamist militants that execute armed operations against government forces in Northern Sinai.

“They [militants] have been present in Northern Sinai for a while, they didn’t all come out of the blue. Why didn't the Bedouins report this issue to the government? There is definitely a common interest between both sides”, he said.

Moussa believes that primary indicators about the planning, preparation and implementation of Wednesday’s militant attack "point to the involvement of the Muslim Brotherhood, especially after considering the timing and aim of the attack."

He believes that the [beleaguered] Muslim Brotherhood has recently managed to regain its “strategic balance” and reorganised itself through cooperation with other movements abroad - groups which also harbour the Brotherhood's goal of “confronting the Egyptian state, bringing down the regime and proving that the armed forces are incapable of handling such confrontation.”

“Such arrangements took place in Turkey via leading figures of the international Muslim Brotherhood organisation. They are all partners in the terrorist attacks' claimed Moussa.

The aftermath of the militant operation should make security forces adopt policies of "widening the circle of suspicion" and "combing of the borders," he argued.

 
Short link:

 

Email
 
Name
 
Comment's
Title
 
Comment
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.
4



Ahmed M Ibrahim
02-07-2015 05:17pm
657-
224+
Egypt's borders
Egypt's borders with the Gaza Enclave, Sudan and Libya have to be fully secured. The border with Libya is extremely vulnerable to attacks from terrorist elements while the Rafah border is a beehive of dangerous tunnels supplying explosives and armaments besides infiltrators from outside. For decades the border with Libya was safe and secure but with the ouster of Muammar Qaddafi, Libya itself has become a "Somalia" on Egypt's border. The border with Sudan is also fully porus. Egypt should immediately secure these borders and intensify co-operation with Israel to tackle the terrorist threat from Gaza enclave.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
3



Imad
02-07-2015 01:42pm
12-
135+
Israel is the source
Israel is helping these terrorists in Syria, now apparently doing the same in Egypt.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
democracia
02-07-2015 03:16pm
125-
42+
Please read
Dear Emad! Israel?Oh no please... You should maybe read the new opinion article on this AO website: "Violent Islamism: Our amazing disgrace", maybe it helps, but I have my doubts....
2



expat
02-07-2015 11:36am
422-
246+
@aladdin
iran has nothing to do with this issue Hamas is the Gaza MB organisation and as the military is trying to cut their supplies,they fight back,together with the IS freaks. For your military question: didnt you know,that sinai is a demilitarised zone? egypt cannot bring too much troops and heavy weaponry on the area without ok from israel, but now they give the ok,as the thread is to both,egypt and israel. it would be best,but impossible for political reasons,if egypt and israel would take the groups behind the attack in a two side combat,encircled them and kill them out for good
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
1



Aladdin, ALex
02-07-2015 03:07am
140-
39+
Intellgence
I suggest to lease Russian spy satellite for early warning supported by traditional ground spy. Is Hamas helping our enemies? Is Iran behind all of this? Why we do not act first instead of responding? I am sure that our military academies are not graduating high caliber offices and engineers.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
Bubbly
02-07-2015 06:36am
311-
459+
don't blame others
Why don't you admit that you , your intelligence agencies, your stratgies failed,you failed to safe guard your soldiers, you soil from terrorists why blaming others..what you were doing..? where are a claims that Sinai has been cleaned in last 2 years operations..? Sir simply admit you failure....this is a total security failure of CC regime...because you are busy eliminating their political opponants, to strenthen your rule and your empire.You have no interest to defend the country.
NewEgypt123
02-07-2015 05:15am
455-
242+
Time for Offense
I agree with you that Egypt must take the initiative and go on the offensive against its enemies rather than playing defense. It has been patient long enough. If there is evidence that a foreign nation is behind these attacks then the goverment must air this information to the public and launch a war against such nation(s). Egypt has built the biggest military in the region, and now it must use it. No more restraint!
NewEgypt123
02-07-2015 05:13am
232-
16+
Time for Offense
I completely agree with you that Egypt needs to act first and go on the offensive rather than react to these groups. Egypt needs to switch the game on its enemies. Egypt has been patient too long with its enemies, so now it is time to take the fight to them. If there is concrete proof that a foreign nation is behind these attacks then the government should air it to the people. The army needs to be bold and launch airstrikes against any of these nations regardless of what the rest of the world thinks. It is clear that Egypt is on its own, so it must act on its own to defend itself. Egypt has built the largest military in the region and now it is time to use it to protect the nation and severely punish its enemies.
NewEgypt123
02-07-2015 05:13am
3-
1+
Time for Offense
I completely agree with you that Egypt needs to act first and go on the offensive rather than react to these groups. Egypt needs to switch the game on its enemies. Egypt has been patient too long with its enemies, so now it is time to take the fight to them. If there is concrete proof that a foreign nation is behind these attacks then the government should air it to the people. The army needs to be bold and launch airstrikes against any of these nations regardless of what the rest of the world thinks. It is clear that Egypt is on its own, so it must act on its own to defend itself. Egypt has built the largest military in the region and now it is time to use it to protect the nation and severely punish its enemies.
Latest

© 2010 Ahram Online.