Last Update 20:58
Monday, 14 October 2019

Russia confirms bomb downed its plane; Egypt to 'take findings into consideration'

Russia says it found evidence that 1Kg bomb caused crash of Airbus A321 over Sinai, offers $50 million reward for related information; Putin vows retribution; Egypt says yet to discover proof of foul play

Ahram Online , Tuesday 17 Nov 2015
Sherif Ismail
In this image released by the Prime Minister's office, Sherif Ismail, right, looks at the remains of a crashed passenger jet in Hassana Egypt, Friday, Oct. 31, 2015 (AP)
Views: 15491
Views: 15491

18:50 Ahram Online concludes its live coverage on the Russian plane crash developments.

18:30 Russia's unilateral announcement that the Russian airbus A321 was downed by a bomb without coordinating with Egypt in advance reflects a political gap between Cairo and Moscow, a military expert told Ahram Online. "If Russia has evidence that the plane was downed by a bomb, why didn't they show it to the Egyptian authorities?" said Mahmoud Qasqosh, a researcher for the Regional Centre for Strategic studies.

"We need to see the actual evidence that the plane was brought down," he said. "Is the proof on surveillance cameras or was a chemical component found to have caused the explosion?" he added. "Eventually, all parties within the investigative committee must issue a final report determining the reason behind the crash."

17:40 Egypt's Ministry of Interior issued a statement announcing that the following security procedures have been implemented at all Egyptian airports:

  • Revising inspection procedures for passengers, luggage and airport workers.
  • Revising inspection procedures and checking permits for all vehicles and drivers on airport grounds.
  • Revising inspection procedures for planes and security permits for plane crews.
  • Cooperating with experts from different countries as well as airline representatives who have expressed concern in the aftermath of the incident. Several such representatives have already praised the newly adopted security measures.

17:30 Egyptian Prime Minister Sherif Ismail said that compensation by Egypt for the families of Russian victims killed in the airliner crash is “unlikely,” as Egypt's investigating committee has not yet issued its final report.

17:20 Egypt stressed its full cooperation with Russian authorities in "combating terrorism," according to a cabinet statement.

17:00 Egyptian Civil Aviation Minister Hossam Kamal said that the Egyptian investigating committee has not yet found any proof that a "criminal act" was behind the Russian plane crash. He stated at a press conference that if evidence of foul play is found, the case will be handled by the Egyptian prosecution and Egypt will be the first to announce the findings of the investigating committee.

16:45 Egyptian Prime Minister Sherif Ismail said that Egypt and the committee leading investigations into the plane crash would take into consideration the findings provided by Russian authorities, which confirmed the airliner was downed by an explosive device.

16:35 Aly Bakr, an expert on Islamist movements, told Ahram Online that the terrorist group claiming to be responsible for downing the Russian plane was targeting Russia over the country's strikes against Islamist militants in Syria. The Sinai-based militant group Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis, which is affiliated with the Islamic State militant group, has claimed responsibility for downing the flight.

Bakr says that the attack is a statement by the group that it has the means to strike at Russia, the US and European countries. "In two weeks we got two terrorist operations in two touristic spots; Paris and Sinai," he said. "This is a direct message that IS is capable of committing large-scale terrorist acts in a short period of time."

Bakr says that what gives IS the ability to undertake such operations is that many of its members have Arab, Russian and European passports, either legitimate or forged, making it easy for them to move across borders.

Nageh Ibrahim, an expert on terrorist movements and an ex-Jihadist, says that downing the airliner was not only a strike against Russia, but also against Egypt. Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis has has been waging an intensified insurgency against the Egyptian army in North Sinai since the ouster of Islamist president Mohamed Morsi in 2013.

16:20 Egypt's Prime Minsiter Sherif Ismail will hold a press conference in Sharm El-Sheikh within the next few minutes, Al-Ahram arabic news website reported.

14:35 Reuters reported that, "one of the security officials said CCTV footage showed a baggage handler carrying a suitcase from an airport building to another man, who was loading luggage onto the doomed airliner from beneath the plane on the runway."

Reuters added that other sources at the Sharm airport said security forces were searching for two employees who are suspected of leaving a baggage-scanning machine unattended for a period of time while passengers were boarding the doomed Russian plane.

Egypt has denied any arrests of Sharm El-Sheikh Airport personnel. Russia also said that they have not received any information of arrests at the airport.

14:20 The Egyptian cabinet headed by Prime Minister Sherif Ismail is currently discussing Tuesday’s announcement by Russia, MENA reported.

Since the Russian plane crash on 31 October, the cabinet has been holding all of its weekly meetings in Sharm El-Sheikh to reassure tourists of the resort’s safety.

The cabinet is also discussing means of revitalising domestic and foreign tourist traffic to the Red Sea city. Over 72,000 Russian tourists have been airlifted from Egyptian resorts in the aftermath of the plane crash, the Russian Tourism Agency was quoted as saying by Al-Ahram Arabic website on Tuesday.

13:30 Former Aviation Minister Wael El-Maadawy tells privately owned channel CBC Extra that it is unclear whether announcements made by Russian President Vladimir Putin regarding the plane crash came following a consultation with Egypt. "All [that we know so far] is the work of intelligence. There was no official statement from the official body [which is led by Egypt] investigating the cause of the crash," he says.

El-Maadawy added that concerned countries should provide Egypt with any information they gather on the causes of the crash. "I believe that Egypt should send an official complaint to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), as no information from any country has been given to Egypt concerning this incident, which could put the lives of many people in danger."

On the possibility of a bomb causing the crash, El-Maadawy said that any country, even one as militarily advanced as France, could be infiltrated. "This is due to a huge development in the ability of militant groups to infiltrate any system in any country," he says.

13:15 Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said that Russian authorities have not received any reports of arrests of Sharm airport employees, Russian news agency Sputnik reports. Earlier in the day, the Egyptian Ministry of Interior had denied media reports claiming the arrest of Sharm El-Sheikh Airport staffers in connection with the crash.

12:50 Egypt’s cabinet will issue a statement soon, according to various media reports.

12:42 The spokesperson for Egypt's Ministry of Foreign Affairs told Ahram Online that he has no information about the Russian announcement, adding that the Ministry of Civil Aviation in Egypt was the party in charge of the investigation. Ahram Online couldn't immediately reach a representative from the latter ministry for a comment.

12:15 Egypt’s interior ministry denied on Tuesday media reports that two Sharm El-Sheikh Airport staff members were arrested in connection with the crash of a Russian passenger airliner over Egypt’s Sinai, state news agency MENA reported.

12:00 The Russian Federal Security Service director offered a reward of $50 million for information on those behind the terror attack on the A321, RT reported.

11:45 Egyptian authorities have detained two employees of Sharm El-Sheikh Airport in connection with the downing of a Russian jet on Oct. 31, killing all 224 people on board, two security officials told Reuters. "Seventeen people are being held, two of them are suspected of helping whoever planted the bomb on the plane at Sharm El-Sheikh airport," one of the officials said.

11:00 Russia's President Vladimir Putin vowed to find and punish the attackers who brought down a plane with 224 people on board in Sinai last month, in remarks released by the Kremlin Tuesday.

"We will search for them anywhere they might hide. We will find them in any part of the world and punish them," Putin told FSB security chief Alexander Bortnikov late Monday, calling the attack "one of the bloodiest crimes".

(Reuters) - The Kremlin said on Tuesday that a bomb had ripped apart a Russian passenger jet over Egypt last month and promised to hunt down those responsible and intensify its air strikes on Islamist militants in Syria in response.

Egypt has opened an investigation into the causes of the crash, and allowed Russia to take part in the probe. No official and final report by Egypt has been issued yet.

Until Tuesday, Russia had played down assertions from Western countries that the crash, in which 224 people were killed on Oct. 31, was a terrorist incident, saying it was important to let the official investigation run its course.

But in a late night Kremlin meeting on Monday three days after Islamist gunmen and bombers killed 129 people in Paris, Alexander Bortnikov, the head of Russia's FSB security service, told a meeting chaired by President Vladimir Putin that traces of foreign-made explosive had been found on fragments of the downed plane and on passengers' personal belongings.

"According to an analysis by our specialists, a homemade bomb containing up to 1 kilogram of TNT detonated during the flight, causing the plane to break up in mid air, which explains why parts of the fuselage were spread over such a large distance," said Bortnikov.

"We can unequivocally say it was a terrorist act," Bortnikov said in footage that was not released until Tuesday morning.

Putin responded by saying the incident was one of the bloodiest acts in modern Russian history and ordered the Russian air force to intensify its air strikes in Syria in response.

"It (our campaign) must be intensified in such a way that the criminals understand that retribution is inevitable," said Putin.

Ordering the country's secret service to hunt down those responsible for blowing up the plane, he said the effort to bring them to justice should be exhaustive.

"We will search for them everywhere wherever they are hiding. We will find them anywhere on the planet and punish them," Putin said.  

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

18-11-2015 07:25am
The West is More Unsafe
Egypt didn't deny/ignore investigations. It only showed its unease & suspicion about Western lack of cooperation. Western intelligences had information about the attack "before" it happened without sharing it: this is a crime against international laws. It's also suspicious the way Russia reacted banning ALL flights, whereas other countries kept incoming flights the same or even more like some Arab countries did supporting Egypt against this smear campaign. The egregious double-standards of Western reporting & reaction r a shame considering the scale of disasters happening in other countries: the dozens killed in "shooting sprees" across America every year; the hundreds by Mexican & Brazilian gangs; the massacre in Norway island, Tunisian resort, Turkey's protest, etc. It's more insecure there than here: taking a flight by depressed Western pilot, walking down a Western street by an imbalanced teenager/neo-Nazi/xenophobe/racist suddenly deciding to kill himself & everyone around, etc.
Comment's Title

17-11-2015 04:34pm
Egypt needs to come clean
Hm. On one hand the Egyptian authorities detain airport workers for smuggling a bomb on the plane, on the other hand they deny that there was a bomb on the plane? Seems that the Egyptian authorities hope to apply the same cover-up/news-blackout/denial strategy that has worked so well in the case of the shot Mexican tourists in the Western Desert. This may be enough to silence critics in Egypt, but not abroad. Ultimately, it will be deeply counterproductive, because it just serves to undermine the international credibility of Egypt's investigations into these events. Politically engineered claims about the supposed safety of Egypt as a tourist destination are the last thing that the tourist industry now needs. It would be much better to come clean, be honest about what went wrong, and do something about it.
Comment's Title

17-11-2015 03:22pm
Damage Control
The defiant Egyptian Government should issue an apology to the Russian people asap, and not double down on their arrogant incompetence. Second, use international help in investigating and questioning all airport employees. Third, and most importantly revisit all domestic security policies, laws, and practices that created the environment for this disaster. Enough playing amateurish games with the Egyptian people and the International community. This is an inflection point in this Government tenure, and how they handle it will determine the survival or collapse of the Egyptian Economy.
Comment's Title

17-11-2015 11:33am
The biggest sponsor of terrorism is Qatar! It is the main source of all terror acts. Al Jazzera is a source of information war. This country have to be cutt off from international relationship.
Comment's Title
17-11-2015 05:32pm
I got three words for you...
Where's the proof?
17-11-2015 03:16pm
AJ international
Al-Jazeera international is an excellent tv channel and is far from doing any propaganda, I don't know if you ever had the chance to watch it..
17-11-2015 03:14pm
Are you sure?
What about Saudi Arabia?

© 2010 Ahram Online.