Last Update 22:17
Sunday, 13 October 2019

Egyptian journalists protest for press freedom, worried about Islamist appointees

The Brotherhood's dominance of the Shura Council, which is responsible for appointing editors to state-owned newspapers, has led some journalists to warn of 'NDP-style' domination of the media

Sarah Mourad, Tuesday 3 Jul 2012
Protestors in front of Journalism Syndicate (Photo: Mohamed Nada)
Views: 2867
Views: 2867

About a hundred journalists from various state-owned newspapers protested in front of the journalists' syndicate on Tuesday afternoon, objecting to interference by the Shura Council (the upper house of Egypt's parliament) in the Supreme Press Council, which is responsible for appointing editors-in-chief of state-owned media.

Journalists chanted: "Don't be afraid and say it, the Shura must leave," "[President] Abdel Nasser said it long ago, the Brotherhood should not be trusted," and "They removed Safwat [El-Sherif, ex-secretary general of the NDP and former head of Shura Council] and brought us Fahmy."

Tuesday is the first day in which candidates for editor-in-chief positions in the country's national newspapers must register, as announced at a press conference on Sunday.

A sub-committee of the Shura Council is responsible for selecting and appointing editors-in-chief and boards of directors for state-owned news organisations. Protesters argue that during Mubarak's presidency, the body used this authority to appoint those who would serve the regime's agenda, and since the Shura Council is currently dominated by Islamists, they fear that newly-appointed editors-in-chief would serve the Islamists' agenda.

The upper house of Egypt's Parliament, which is dominated by the Muslim Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice Party (FJP) and the Salafist Nour Party, oversees the press council.

Other journalists were also present at the protest, objecting to its message. One man shouted: "Shame on you people! Morsi has been a president for only a few days!" while a woman asked: "What is your problem? Do you want those spoiled editors-in-chief to remain in power?" which caused tension between both sides.

Khaled Dawood, journalist at Ahram Weekly newspaper, said that they had decided to hold their protest in the interests of the independence of the media, as "what is happening now is the same as Mubarak's National Democratic Party system and tactics, where people in authority appoint their relatives and friends."

Dawood is worried that since the Shura Council's speaker Ahmed Fahmy, who supervises the Supreme Press Council, is President Mohamed Morsi's relative and a leading member in the Freedom and Justice Party, new editors-in-chief will be chosen that serve the interests of those in power. 

Dawood believes that there should be a general assembly in each newspaper responsible for appointing the editor-in-chief, with no interference from parliament.

Alaa El-Attar, a member of the journalists' syndicate board, believes that the question of who the editors-in-chief are is only a sub-issue of the main problem - that the entire system is corrupt.

"The Supreme Press Council's rules all needs to be changed and reformed. We need reform of the entire system. Even if the prominent veteran writer and journalist Mohamed Hassanein Heikal was appointed editor-in-chief tomorrow morning, the system would still be the same," El-Attar said.

Journalist Fatma Shaarawy, who works at Al-Ahram newspaper, said that it does not make any sense that the Shura Council has such authority to appoint editors-in-chief. She argues that journalism should be independent, in the sense that newspapers have independent general assemblies responsible for that matter."

Sayed Abdel Khaleq, who is a journalist at Akhbar El-Yom newspaper, agreed with Shaarawi, adding that the terms used by the Shura Council for appointing editors-in-chief are very insulting and make the new editors-in-chief secretaries to the council.

"The Islamists are dominating everything and following the same tactics, just like the NDP used to, and maybe even worse. It's like they want to take revenge on national newspapers for attacking them in the past," Abdel Khaleq said.

In a report released last month, the Shura Council set its criteria for selecting the new appointees, and said that deteriorated financial and administrative conditions in state-owned press organisations are the result of the interference by those in power in the management of those organisations.

The report also stated that the Shura Council, "the real owner of those institutions," gave up on its role, ultimately allowing individuals to be promoted according to the whims of power, which led to deficiencies in organisational structure and internal dictatorships.

The report also announced seven measures and three conditions for hiring new chief editors including implementing an age limit and a minimum requirement of 15 years experience. Also that no chief editor will be appointed if he was proven to be involved in a corruption case.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

Abdur Razzaque
05-07-2012 11:26am
Journalists Freedom in Egypt!
Being a Muslim country Egypt is, everybody should honour and respect their Islamic ideology and beliefs. Islam is the only religion that is more than compatible and comparable with the modern democratic rights. Islamic rights is so strong that any civilian regardless has right to accuse even a head of the state with sufficient proof. If it is, why we are so worried about the en coming Egyptian constitution and its nature? Good is always good and will remain as good forever.
Comment's Title

Jon Erland Madsen
04-07-2012 12:14pm
The state should not own media
While media all over the world seem most concerned with entertaining and earning money, they still play an important role in the supervision of politics, the conduct of the police, the military and the judiciary. This role is called the "fourth state power" and is probably indispensable for a functioning democracy. It does not function if the ones supposed to be controlled themselves control the media. The Egyptian state controlled media should thus be sold to the private sector as soon as possible. One option is to give them / sell them to their present employees.
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.