Last Update 20:55
Wednesday, 23 October 2019

Morsi meets opposition to discuss Ethiopia dam, while some boycott

Some liberal opponents of the president attend but a number of opposition figures, including Hamdeen Sabbahi and Amr Moussa, skip a meeting to discuss the controversial new Ethiopian dam

Ahram Online, Monday 3 Jun 2013
Mohammed Morsi
Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi (Photo: AP)
Views: 2757
Views: 2757

Egyptian political figures and parties were divided over whether to take part in a presidential meeting on Monday which will look into the impact of a new Nile dam being built by Ethiopia.

President Morsi called for the meeting to look into the findings of a report drawn up by a panel of experts on the impact of the Renaissance Dam on water supplies in Sudan and Egypt.

While some of the invitees – including a handful of opposition figures – accepted the invitation to attend the meeting, which started on Monday afternoon, others appeared to question its efficacy.

Some liberal, leftist groups agree to attend

The liberal Egypt Freedom Party, founded by political scientist and activist Amr Hamzawy, expressed its intention to take part.

"Despite our differences with President Morsi's administration and our calls for early presidential elections, the party has accepted the invitation due to its commitment to protecting the state's interests and Egyptian water security," said Hamzawy.

Other groups participating in the meeting are the liberal Al-Wafd party and the Popular Socialist Alliance.

Both Al-Wafd and the Egypt Freedom parties are members of the National Salvation Front (NSF), Egypt's largest opposition coalition.

The Strong Egypt Party announced on Monday it would not attend the meeting because party head Abdel-Moneim Abul-Fotouh is currently out of country, and only party heads were invited to attend. The party had earlier announced plans to take part.

Citing the findings of the report, a statement by the president’s office said Ethiopia's "studies [of the dam’s impact] were not adequate for a project of this scale." The report recommended more studies of the economic and social aspects of the dam, of the security of the dam and of water resources, and of the environmental impact of the dam, the statement read.

Other opposition groups express concerns about transparency

Mohamed ElBaradei's Constitution Party officially announced on Sunday it would not join the talks, citing scepticism over the seriousness of the dialogue and concerns about a lack of information and transparency in addressing an issue of great sensitivity, according to party spokesman Khaled Dawood.

The Free Egyptians Party for its part declined on Sunday what it deemed as an "absurd" invitation, citing the incompetence of the presidency in tackling a range of national security matters. These include, according to the party, the presidency's handling of the abduction of Egyptian security personnel in Sinai in May, as well as the polarisation caused by Egypt's new constitution.

In a Sunday statement, the party stressed that the goals of the meeting were undefined, and it demanded that talks over associated risks not be held behind closed doors.

The statement went on to slam the timing of the meeting as an attempt to distract Egyptians from crucial domestic issues, citing a planned protest by judges on Monday as well as a Sunday court ruling against the constitutionality of the upper house of parliament and the constitution-drafting committee.

A difference of opinion within the NSF coalition regarding Sunday’s meeting was evident, with some members accepting the invitation to attend and others declining

Despite officially announcing on Sunday he would take part, head of the Egyptian Social Democratic Party and member of the NSF Mohamed Abul-Ghar backtracked following dissatisfaction expressed by party members and opposition figures about his participation.

Amr Moussa, head of the Conference Party and NSF member, also reconsidered the invitation after officially announcing he would take part "regardless of his opposition to the government over domestic issues." Moussa cited reasons including maintaining the unity of the National Salvation Front, which normally boycotts talks with the president.

Both Abul-Ghar and Moussa said they would instead send a memo on the issue to the president.

Hamdeen Sabbahi, head of the Egyptian Popular Current and a founding member of the NSF, announced he would not join the meeting without citing reasons.

The group of political figures invited to look into the committee’s findings also included Mohamed El-Katatni, head of the Muslim Brotherhood's Freedom and Justice Party, Younis Makhyoun, head of the Salafist-oriented Nour Party, Amr Khaled, Islamic preacher and head of the Masr Party, Hazem Abu-Ismail, a former Salafist presidential candidate, and Ayman Nour, head of the liberal Ghad El-Thawra party.

Ethiopia began last Tuesday diverting the course of the Blue Nile, one of the Nile River’s two major tributaries, as part of its project to build a new $4.7 billion hydroelectric dam. The move has heightened concerns in Egypt and Sudan, both dependent on the world's longest river for water.

Ethiopia's officials, however, moved to dispel fears over the dam's impact, stressing it would benefit riparian countries.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

04-06-2013 09:59pm
I am confused?!?!
I am from Ethiopia, and may my comment will look sided to Ethiopia ( to my country).But, before I gave my vote to my country about our dam , let's someone explain to me the question of Egypt government/people with clear language. Because, it look like we are asking/begging (as usual) our own property. Look like to ask some opinion to swallow or not the food you already chew. Is that fare, or is that a reasonable question? I don't think so! that is why I am confused. For example, I may not a political supporter of my own government, but not with the cost of poor Ethiopian brother, sister, kids and old ( mother and fathers). I don't think anyone who has a blood of Ethiopia will support this unfair request of Egypt, even Eritreans. I don't know the status of our military in a current period, but we don't need to have a best military weapons to stop anyone who ask us anything unfair with a cost of our country. It's not our history, it 's never happen for us. For Some who can explain my question in the above, may be from Egypt , I have straight response. If you can believe that your replay convincing me 100%, don't even write to me prepare yours self for war, that can be finish within short period of time. Because, it's unfair and unreasonable interest of your country, and can't be concluded with wining the undefeatable people by anyone in Africa, a land of strong dreamful and strong BLACK peoples.
Comment's Title

03-06-2013 03:25pm
with regards to Nile Dam
85% of the Nile river water emanates from Ethiopia and the user of the whole water is Egypt. Ethiopia had never benefited from the river ant it is the time to consume the water with out inflicting damage on Egypt. Ethiopia has the right to use its own river.
Comment's Title
04-06-2013 02:57pm
Where is the problem of the dam?
The dam is just to generate electricity and the water continues the natural course. Therefore, what is the basis for some Egyptians to oppose Ethiopia getting electricity? The Nile is an excess to Egypt and flowing to Meditranian, why Egypt never wory about the excess rather than being Jealous!

© 2010 Ahram Online.