Last Update 0:58
Wednesday, 22 May 2019

Egypt's live TV coverage of Nile crisis meeting draws fire

Candid statements by Egyptian political figures regarding Ethiopia's contentious Nile dam move – aired on live TV without their knowledge – draw scathing criticism, mockery from President Morsi's detractors

Sherif Tarek , Tuesday 4 Jun 2013
Nile crisis meeting
Egyptian President Mohammed Morsi, center, meets with politicians at the Presidential Palace in Cairo, Egypt, Monday, June 3, 2013 (Photo: AP)
Share/Bookmark
Views: 8006
Share/Bookmark
Views: 8006

A host of unguarded statements made at a meeting between Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi and political figures held to discuss the Ethiopia dam 'crisis' have prompted a wave of criticism against Egypt's already-under-fire government decision-makers.

Walking into Monday's meeting unaware that the event was being aired on live television, Egyptian figures from across the political spectrum candidly spoke their minds, with many making what were seen as offensive suggestions as to how to deal with the ongoing controversy over Ethiopia's Grand Renaissance Dam project.

While Morsi did not respond to any of the controversial statements made at the meeting, his aide for political affairs, Pakinam El-Sharqawy, has since apologised for failing to inform attendees that the 'national dialog' meeting was being broadcast live.

"It was initially planned that the national meeting would be recorded and aired the following day as is usually the case, but due to the importance of the topic it was decided at the last minute to air the meeting live," she said via Facebook late on Monday. "I forgot to inform attendees of the changes."

Her apology, however, failed to offset her – or the speakers' – embarrassment.

The well-known 'We Are All Khaled Saeed' Facebook page – which played a prominent role in mobilising the public for Egypt's 2011 revolution – said of the affair: "How can a meeting held to discuss a national security issue... be televised live without attendees' knowledge?"

The page also blamed El-Sharqawy, who attended the meeting, for not immediately informing participants – especially once they began speaking bluntly – that the meeting was being broadcast live. "Is this appropriate planning from the presidency of a country with Egypt's status?" page administrators asked.

For his part, leading opposition figure Mohamed ElBaradei, who had refused to take part in Monday's meeting, described the statements made at the event as "irresponsible." He went on to issue his "sincere apologies to the people and governments of Ethiopia and Sudan" for what was said by meeting participants.

'Maintaining secrecy'

At the meeting, liberal politician Ayman Nour said that "Sudan's stance on the crisis is disgusting," before suggesting that Egypt spread false rumours about an impending Egyptian airstrike on the Ethiopian dam. Promoting such a rumour, said Nour, "could yield results on the diplomatic track."

In comments made via Twitter following the meeting, Nour, head of the liberal Ghad El-Thawra Party, expressed his "surprise" that the meeting had been televised live. He said attendees had not been informed of this fact, "despite the sensitivity of the situation."

Salafist Nour Party leader Younis Makhioun, who also seemed unaware that the meeting was being aired live, stated that destroying the dam should be a last resort.

First, Makhioun recommended backing Ethiopian rebel movements against Addis Ababa. "We can communicate with them and use them as a bargaining chip against the Ethiopian government," he said.

"If this fails, Egypt will have no choice but to play its final card: using the intelligence apparatus to destroy the dam," said Makhioun, whose Nour Party won roughly one quarter of the seats in parliament in 2011/12 elections.

Mohamed Anwar El-Sadat, chairman of the liberal Reform and Development Party, elaborated on the role that should be played by Egypt's intelligence apparatus, again referring to Ethiopian rebels who might be co-opted by Egyptian intelligence.

"Ethiopia [consists] of multiple tribes, and your Excellency [Morsi] knows that everybody in Africa can be bribed," he said.

After several other speakers candidly spoke their minds, Magdi Hussein, leader of the Islamist-leaning New Labour Party, urged attendees to "maintain the secrecy" of what was said at the meeting – before being told that the event was being carried on live television.

Diplomatic incident?

Due to its Mubarak-era foreign policies, which neglected relations with African nations, Egypt over the last three decades has barely been seen by most African states as part of the continent.

On several occasions, the Morsi administration has pledged to repair Egypt's damaged relations with its African counterparts. Such hopes, however, appear to have been dealt a serious setback in the wake of Monday's unfortunate meeting.

"These are the people who will restore our relations with Africa," veteran journalist and opposition figure Ibrahim Isaa said sarcastically in televised comments following the meeting.

Mostafa El-Guindy, former MP and vice-president of the Pan-African Parliament (the African Union's legislative body), who had been involved in previous talks between Egypt and Nile Basin countries, described Monday's meeting as a "disaster."

"A child would know that such matters cannot be discussed this way," El-Guindy, who is also a member of the 'Popular Diplomacy' initiative (which aims at resolving the current impasse with Ethiopia), said in televised comments.

"What happened is high treason and will turn all African nations against us," he said. "We [the Popular Diplomacy initiative] must hold a popular press conference as a national duty to reject what was said [at Monday's national dialog meeting] and stress that Ethiopians and Africans are our brothers."

Tension between Egypt and Ethiopia escalated last week after the latter abruptly diverted part of the Blue Nile, which represents Egypt's chief source of Nile water. The move, seen as an essential step towards building the country's planned Grand Renaissance Dam, came in the immediate wake of a visit to Ethiopia by President Morsi.

Egypt – fearing the move's impact on its traditional supply of Nile water – quickly summoned the Ethiopian ambassador in Cairo to express its displeasure.

Ethiopian officials, for their part, have attempted to dispel fears regarding the dam's potential impact on downstream states, insisting that the project would ultimately benefit all riparian states.

The Blue Nile provides Egypt with the lion's share of its annual allotment of 55 billion cubic metres of river water.  

Short link:

 

Email
 
Name
 
Comment's
Title
 
Comment
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.
11



Tesfaye
05-06-2013 09:30pm
2-
2+
I don't know why?
It is true that even this evening you every government official may take shower and drink nile water and it is blood of Egypt, however you don't bite the Mother of the river who abundantly bless you for the centuries with fresh water and soil. Let me teach you history only county who never been colonized and symbol of freedom for Africa is Ethiopia after all if you are African. cooperation is the only way that will work in 21 century brother and sisters.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
10



aderu
05-06-2013 02:28pm
0-
2+
Egyptian public deserves better politicians
The biggest challenge we have in Egypt is not the water scarcity, or the public opinion but lack of leadership and long term vision from politicians. Unless what we think, what we say and what we do are not in harmony, we loose our first resolve to form the thought image in our minds and hearts to a a lasting solution. A leadership quality of Anwar is required in Egypt that turns around and strives to long term Nile Solution. The dam is a piece of the iceberg in the whole Nile issue. We are sorry the great people of Egyptians public have such short-sighted politicians. They don't deserve it.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
9



Teklay
05-06-2013 02:18pm
0-
2+
Blue nile
We are happy and thanks to Egypt TV because the Tv program broadcast (what we Ethiopians know before) to the world and the world can understand what the Egyptians are. We Ethiopians should Keep watching those Egyptians living and working in Ethiopia. One thing to egyptians as we are building Reinansance dam you have also Aswan Dam.Their fate can be equal if try any foolish measure.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
8



Bire
05-06-2013 01:31pm
0-
0+
Dual Identity
I always believe that the only time most Egyptians are Africans is during the African Cap of Nations tournament.Otherwise, they prefer to be counted with their Arab brothers. Whatever their case is they are bonded with Ethiopia forever by fate.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
7



Hiwote
05-06-2013 11:39am
0-
0+
Shame on the Government of Egypt
what do they mean when they say the Government of Egypt didn't know that this was broadcasted live on there national TV.i believe they wanted there people to see it and also pass along the message to Ethiopia and also clearly state there stand on the construction of the dam, and i say they have done it so well. SHAME ON THEM!
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
6



Gerie
05-06-2013 10:56am
0-
0+
Shame on you
Being African specially from the so called Civilized Arab country Egypt, I don't expect such down failed idea from BIG POLITICIANS. The time is over using your fist on your neighbors, the time is civilized & keeping mutual benefit by negotiation. What I warn you is that before you do evil deeds against Renaissance believe that it is your END.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
5



Karim Selim
04-06-2013 10:29pm
0-
46+
Apology to Ethiopian beautiful people!!
Dear Ethiopian people, on behalf of millions of Egyptiens who have been just like you shocked by hearing the shameful statments made by some of our officials. As an Egyptien citizen I want you to know that this kind of misconduct doesn't respresent me and alot of my fellw egyptiens who respect and love your great country. Please accept our sincerest apologies for any harm we may have caused. God bless Ethiopia and Egypt.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
alu
05-06-2013 09:48pm
0-
0+
we accept your APPOLOGY KARIM
love you KARIM SELIM,a briliant egyptian brother.
4



Sam
04-06-2013 09:28pm
5-
11+
Shame on ignorant Egyptian poiticians (apart from Morsi and Elbaraday)
Morsi should change govt. With these incomptent politicians Egypt is hopeless. Beacuse the politicans suggested force but nothing else to settle the Nile issue which is the easiest and even a kid in the streets can suggest these solutions. You do not need to be a politician or be educated to suggest such a non-sense and futile means. These people have no idea of where Ethiopia stands at present or the disastrous consequences they would face if they attempt force. Egypt and Sudan have both built 4 big dams on the Nile while Ethiopia still mega-damless on the nile while contributing 85% of the water for their prosperity, which made them look down at Ethiopia. Morsi should fill his governement with more comptent, less extrimist and well educated people. It seems it is only himself and few who realy understood the situation.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
medo
04-06-2013 10:18pm
3-
42+
@sam
@sam, Morsi gave these people these government jobs... and he continues to give jobs to people who are not fit for the roles they have! That is what people are fighting for and have been doing!!
3



Extraterrstrial
04-06-2013 08:45pm
15-
24+
RESPECT FOR AL BARADEI
As an Ethiopian I give my Respect for Mohamed ElBaradei, it tells me there are some good Egyptian. He must be very different from majority Egyptian who try to look down Africans, IT IS GOD EXPOSED YOUR TRUE COLOR OF EGYPT. My question to Egyptian is why you hate us because we feed you with fresh water and fertile soil, why?
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
2



zereyaquob kassa
04-06-2013 08:32pm
4-
12+
What does he mean?
Mohamed Anwar El-Sadat, chairman of the liberal Reform and Development Party said "...everybody in Africa can be bribed." One can conclude that he is an African and hence by his own affirmation bribable. Or he is an African that does not know to be an African , or worse, he believes to be a non African African. Beware here lies the core of centuries long misbehavior of Egyppt against Ethiopia.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
Latest

© 2010 Ahram Online.