Last Update 21:27
Finally Egypt sees Mubarak in a cage
Ahram Online is on the scene as Egypt sees the world's first trial of a former leader in a civil court in his own country
Dina Samak, Wednesday 3 Aug 2011
Share/Bookmark
Views: 14189


Mubarak trial: This combination image made from video taken from Egyptian State Television shows different scenes of 83-year-old Hosni Mubarak on a hospital bed inside a cage of mesh and iron bars in a Cairo courtroom Wednesday, Aug. 3, 2011 as his historic trial began on charges of corruption and ordering the killing of protesters during the uprising that ousted him. (AP Photo/Egyptian State television)
Mubarak: After months of protests and hundreds of martyrs, many of the revolutionary youth were keen to be as near to Mubarak's cage as possible even if this meant protesting in the sun for ours and then seeing him on a TV screen (Photo by: Dina Samak)
Mubarak: 'Insulting a military person is an insult to the whole army' reads a banner held by one of Mubarak supporters (Photo by: Dina Samak)
Mubarak supporters wear T shirts saying 'I am Egyptian and refuse the insult of the leader of the na Mubarak supporters wear T shirts saying 'I am Egyptian and refuse the insult of the leader of the nation". Later clashes erupted between them and the anti Mubarak protesters and families of the martyrs (Photo by: Dina Samak)
Mubarak: "President Mubarak is the first one to support the revolution and defend it" reads a banner held by some of the few tens of protesters who gathered outside the police academy to show their support of the ousted president (Photo by: Dina Samak)

Judge: What do you say to the charges you are facing?

Mubarak: I deny them completely
 
These were ousted president Hosni Mubarak's first words to an Egyptian court today, echoed in turn by family members and former acoltytes, all of them facing charges of ordering the killing of protesters and indulging in staggering acts of corruption.
 
The ousted president lay in the court cage flanked by his two sons, Alaa and Gamal Mubarak, the former interior minister Habib El Adly, and six of his top former officers -- all radiating health and arrogance. Just one figure was missing, Hussein Salem, under house arrest in Spain and being tried in absentia.
 
The huge courtroom had space for at least a thousand people but was half-empty. Those in attendance seemed to be mainly police officers, some in plainclothes, the rest in more formal wear.
 
The seated area around the court's cage was surrounded by an iron fence and entirely inhabited by policemen who deliberately blocked the view for other spectactors.
 
Even a close look at the cage revealed every defendant except Mubarak, his two sons standing beside him taking care to shield him from view. 
 
They weren't entirely successful; state TV cameras were able to capture close-ups of the former president reclined on his gurney, a disdainful look on his face, his hair once again dyed jet black. The 83 year-old chief defendant didn't look very sick or depressed after all.
 
It was more than an hour into the proceedings before those in attendance -- and the millions watching on television -- finally heard the voice of the ousted president, his case being read after those of former interior minister Habib El-Adly and his one-time officers.
 
"Mohamed Hosni El-Sayed Mubarak, are you present?" asked the judge.
 
Everyone stood to see where the answer would come from.
 
"Present, your honour," growled the old man, with as much determination and pride as he could muster.
 
There were only a few journalists in the courtroom to see it, and those present had to surrender their cameras and mobiles beforehand.
 
The legal teams of the defendants totalled around 50 people. Of the lawyers representing revolution martyrs and those injured in the uprising, only 80 were allowed -- the majority were not.
 
Just four of those who have filed law suits against Mubarak were allowed inside the courtroom but they were hardly noticeable in the high drama of the occasion.
 
Strict and grim-faced, the judge, Ahmed Refaat, started the session with a brief statement: 
 
"Egypt is a great country and deserves this historic moment. We are all very proud to be here."
 
He asked everyone to remain seated and silent unless asked otherwise and then the court called the names of defendants and the lawyers representing them. 
 
Mubarak's lawyer, Fareed El-Dib, asked for a copy of the investigations into the former president and then requested he be tried separately from former interior minister El-Adly. The court only recently decided to combine the two trials and the request for a separate trial was repeated by several of the other lawyers.
 
Lawyers on both sides also requested the attendance of field Marshall Hussein Tantawi, head of Egypt's ruling military council, and also Omar Suleiman, former vice president and once head of the Egyptian intelligence service.
 
The two cases were called separately.
 
Habib El-Adly's lawyer, Mohammed Abdel Fatah, claimed El-Adly and his assistant Ismail El Shair had nothing to do with the killing of protesters. He insisted it was the former interior minister who had requested an open trial to be able to prove their innocence to the public, claiming many of the incidences of murder did not take place.
 
The polished, clear delivery of Fatah, and his colleagues on the defence teams, stood in stark contrast to the lawyers representing the families of the martyrs who seemed disorganised and slightly confused in comparison.
 
Speaking in the name of those killed by his alleged orders, the latter demanded that Mubarak be kept in Tora prison hospital during the trial.
 
They also called on media and communications companies as witnesses with the aim of questioning them to discover how mobile phones and the internet were blocked on 28 January and who gave the relevant orders. Others considered Egyptian state media as a partner in the crime of killing protesters, demanding they be included in the case.
 
The prosecution accused Mubarak of killing protesters and corrupt practices in international gas deals and abusing his position to acquire valuable properties.
 
Mubarak's case was adjourned until 15 August when more witnesses will be heard. El-Adly's case was adjourned until tomorrow.
 
The distance between the courtroom and the main entrance of the northern Cairo Police Academy was over one kilometre and only police cars were allowed inside, meaning everyone else in attendance was transferred by bus. Inside the academy grounds, army trucks, hundreds of police and Egyptian special forces -- including the notorious 777 special ops unit -- lined the approach.
 
Outside in the streets of the northern Cairo district of Tagammu El-Khames, dozens of martyrs' families and activists stood chanting "where is the justice?" and "thieves and murderers". Many of the journalists, lawyers and families of victims were enraged they were not allowed inside the courtroom to see the proceedings.
 
Nearby were dozens of pro-Mubarak supporters weaning t-shirts splashed with slogans: "I am Egyptian and against insulting the symbol of the nation," was written on some; "Sons of Mubarak," read others. These demonstrators were enraged too, but for quite different reasons. Furious that Mubarak's trial was finally underway they threated to break into the compound and free the former president from his cage. 
 
Before long they were involved in bitter clashes, both with security forces and the anti-Mubarak crowds. It escalated into a fight between factions, rocks and bottles being hurled by both sides. Ahram Online saw seven people injured, one of them a cameraman for a TV news channel. The health ministry later announced 53 had been wounded in the clashes.
 
Fighting, though, was sporadic, fizzling out as attention turned to the massive screen erected outside the academy which showed events inside the courtroom.
 
"It's going to be a long trial but at least he is in jail," said a passer-by as we left. "No one knows what will happen next." 
 
It was hard to tell whether he sympathised with the aged dictator or with the families of the hundreds dead, but he was surely right in what he said.




Short link:

 

Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 4000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.
8



Diana Hughes
08-08-2011 05:58pm
0-
0+
Hosny in trouble again
I agree with you, Ossama, 100per cent. Everything you have said is true. Very good.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
7



Noor- Bahrain
04-08-2011 01:48pm
0-
0+
Hamad is next
Hamad Al Kahlif should prepare himself for a similar day because he gave orders to kill, arrest, torture and fire peaceful protestors in Bahrain and for his crime of allwoing foreign countries's armies (Saudi& Emarati) to invade his country and kill his people. All Arab dictators will face the same fate as Mubarak because they are criminals.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
6



KlausLondon
04-08-2011 10:48am
0-
0+
bitter necessity
Mubarack brought this on himself. Experience in other countries that were in a similar situation (East Germany, South Africa and many more) has shown that there is no option to "move on" as long as the truth about the past is being denied.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
5



Adam
04-08-2011 12:40am
0-
0+
Ridiculous
"Mubarak did well for Egypt during his administration." You are insane. He ruined the country. That is blindingly obvious to anyone who walks down the streets of Cairo. "Show me a country in this world that does not have some government corruption!!!'" So what you're saying is that because there is illegal activity everywhere, we should not punish illegal activity anywhere.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
4



Jerry
03-08-2011 10:43pm
0-
0+
Same for all dictators
@ Ossama. You right but that doesnt mean he should get away with his crimes.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
3



Muhagir
03-08-2011 10:37pm
0-
0+
Missing the point
While it is a pity that so much time and energy has to be wasted on trying this man, let us not minimize what he did. Under his rule the people of Egypt did not enjoy one day of freedom without emergency rule. Anyone could be harassed, humiliated, and arbitrarily detained under the pretense of fighting terrorism. Khalid Said was just one of many. Egypt was so good at torture that the US sent terror suspects there to be "questioned". Egypt willingly participated in isolating and starving Gaza. Do you need more? Please don't dismiss all of this as just corruption. He was a criminal.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
2



American Muse
03-08-2011 09:04pm
0-
0+
Wecome
By golly, who's next? Must be George Bush and his cohorts, Rummy and Cheney! Didn't they start illegal wars, kill tens of thousands of innocent Afghans and Iraqis, and commit war crimes and crimes against humanity? If natural justice prevails, you'll see their trial happen one day sooner or later, mark my words. Whoever thought Mubarak & Co. would be there now? It is their just desserts.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
1



Ossama
03-08-2011 06:53pm
0-
1+
Disappointment
It is a disappointment to see Egyptians put so much emphases and energy on Mubarak's trial during these critical times. This trial shows that the revolution is energized by hate and revenge two ingredients leading to failure! Mubarak did well for Egypt during his administration. Show me a country in this world that does not have some government corruption!!!
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment

© 2010 Ahram Online. Advertising