Last Update 5:57
Monday, 21 May 2018

Egypt still reeling from 1967 War defeat: Naim Sabri

Defeat in the 1967 War ended the dream of a civil democratic Egyptian state, but novelist Naim Sabri sees hope for the future

Dina Ezzat, Tuesday 5 Jun 2012
1967 War
Israeli vehicles in the Sinai Peninusla in Egypt during the Six-Day War.(Photo: Reuters)
Views: 2634
Views: 2634

It has been 45 years since Egypt and its Arab allies were defeated by Israel in the Six Day War.

The defeat led to the occupation of Egyptian and other Arab land, including East Jerusalem. An equally troubling outcome was the eventual retreat of calls for a strong civil state, which Egyptian president Gamal Abdel-Nasser had been working towards in the decade prior to the defeat.

"Ultimately, we ended up with a scenario in which the nation was faced with two choices: the power of the military or the power of political Islam," said novelist Naim Sabri in an interview with Ahram Online. "This was not immediate, but inevitable."

Sabri's novels, including his famous Shubra, examine the deep and often disturbing change in Egyptian society over recent decades. The starting point is usually the eve of Egypt's 1952 Revolution, which brought the monarchy to an end and launched a republic in which the military would play a central role.

A clear theme in Sabri's work is the changing role of religion in society, from a spiritual exercise in the 1950s and 1960s to a socio-economic one later on, which not only contributed little to society's evolution but actually ended up fostering intellectual stagnation.

"The 1967 defeat led to a loss of hope and aspiration; it was a moment of despair when society was searching for any exit, hence the turn to political Islam," Sabri said.

The rise of the 'pious president'

Anwar Sadat became president when Nasser died in 1970, and after Egypt's victory in the 1973 war, Sabri argued, Sadat, whose base of support was primarily within the military, turned to Islamist movements in an attempt to destroy the leftist opposition.

"Sadat had a political motive to eliminate, one way or another, his political opponents, especially in the student movement, and to serve this purpose he turned to Islamist movements," Sabri recalled.

After Sadat established himself as a war hero in 1973, he worked on becoming the "pious president."

"His name had always been Anwar Sadat but suddenly it became Mohamed Anwar Sadat to emphasise his Islamic identity, and he called himself a Muslim president of a Muslim state. Sectarian tension grew and the rest is history," Sabri stated.   

By the time Islamist militants within the army assassinated Sadat at a military parade in 1981, Egypt had already lost hope of establishing a modern civil state and gone far towards becoming a military/religious state.

Back in the early eighties, Sabri argued, "People were vulnerable, despair prevailed and the economy was on the decline as all the state's funds were being used to rebuild a thoroughly defeated army."

Hopes for the future

Sabri is dismayed with the outcome of the presidential election first round but is still hopeful for the future.

Over the past 45 years, as Sabri's novels reflect, Egypt has undergone many negative currents: the decline of the middle class, the 1967 military defeat, the rise of political Islam, and the expansion of the military/security apparatus. But since the 2011 uprising, Sabri has observed new hope for a modern, democratic and civil state, although "maybe not right away."

When the Six Day War defeat hit the nation back in 1967, Sabri was still an engineering student at Cairo University. "It was a moment of shock; it was a moment when we realised we had been cheated by the state and its media to believe that we were strong and undefeatable," he recalled.

Egypt is facing difficult challenges: the military-Islamist polarisation, the division of the moderate political forces, the lack of an astute political leadership and the grave miscalculations of the ruling Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, Sabri said. However, he added, these are challenges that Egypt can deal with due to the youth's hope and energy, as opposed to the despair that captivated the youth back in 1967.

For Sabri, it is the triumph of hope over despair that makes all the difference, no matter what the challenges might be.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

06-06-2012 11:48am
What an amazing story and insight into modern day Egypt!
This story about an tragic incident 45 years ago is chock full of insight into present-day Egypt. Now, at last, I can see how it was absolutely inevitable that, just as two heavyweight boxers vying for the title of Champion would now be going mano a mano for the rule of Egypt. Perhaps Naim is spot on when he says the youthly democrats will prevail, eventually. But, will the youth that inherits the mantel be the youth of today, or must it wait until 2025 or 2050? Rather than force present-day Egypt to suffer the result of this polarized battle between military rule or religious rule, can this great people, descendants of Ramses, not now rise up and chant, "We want democratic-based freedom. We choose Sabbahi as our leader, and Abul Futouh and Khaled Ali as our Vice Presidents. We choose the Egyptian Way in 2012!"
Comment's Title

Yossi Amitay
05-06-2012 10:27pm
Cheers to Naim
I was acquainted with Naim Sabri when I attended some of the meetings of "Nadwat Naguib Mahfouz" at Shephard's Hotel in the late 1990s. I truly like him as a human being and an intriguing novelist who is attentive to the feelings of his people. By the same token I like his novels, some of which I have read with great interest. Above all, I share his opinion that "it is the triumph of hope over despair that makes all the differece". Good luck, my dear friend.
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.