Last Update 21:48
Monday, 16 July 2018

Tahrir protesters react to reports of Mubarak 'clinical death'

Protesters demonstrating in Tahrir Square against military rule believe reports of Mubarak's death a state ruse to distract disaffected Egypt

Bel Trew, Wednesday 20 Jun 2012
Hosni Mubarak
File photo: Members of the special forces stand guard while former Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak lies on a bed while being taken to the courtroom at the police academy in Cairo in this September 7, 2011 (Photo: Reuters)
Views: 3407
Views: 3407

Cheers erupted and fireworks were let off as reports that toppled president Hosni Mubarak was pronounced "clinically dead" trickled into Tahrir Square.

"After 30 years of a brutal regime, the people wanted to say yes, they won for just a day, of course they are rejoicing" says Kawsar Abdel-Atti, 40, a house wife form Sharabaya who had taken her six children to Cairo's flashpoint square earlier that evening to "celebrate Mohamed Morsi's win."

"Large crowds also left the square as they felt sad that an old man had died – we're Egyptians, it doesn't matter who it is, we feel bad if someone dies," her eldest son, Ahmed Abdel-Atti, a 19-year-old computer science student added.

Others, however, believed there were darker state intentions behind the decision to release this breaking piece of news, particularly when reports began circulating that the imprisoned leader was in fact not dead.

General Said Abbas, a member of the ruling military council, told Reuters that the imprisoned former president had suffered a stroke but added: "Any talk of him being clinically dead is nonsense."

Another military source said: "He is completely unconscious. He is using artificial respiration."

A member of the military council, General Mamdouh Shaheen, then told CNN: "He is not clinically dead as reported, but his health is deteriorating and he is in critical condition."

The celebrations quickly fizzled out when banned presidential contender Hazem Abu-Ismail took to the stage "to tell people to quieten down as it's a lie" adds Ahmed.

"The military just wanted to make big news that would eclipse the Tahrir protests about the ruling military council, the elections and the amended constitution," Mohammed Tarek, 27, an interior designer said, "It worked; the media suddenly started talking about Mubarak, and people started to leave the square."

Sabri, a 43-year-old music instructor, who boycotted the elections but was in Tahrir Square to protest the constitutional addendum, said he thought it was a government-spread rumour. Notably, he added, as the first news of Mubarak's 'so-called' death came from government news agency MENA.

"The ruling military council is playing games with us – just like they did with the trial," Sabri says.

"For example they cleared Mubarak and his sons of corruption charges, even though here in Egypt we have lost so much money: money is exactly what we need more than anything else, as it decides your dignity and destiny. Of course the SCAF would protect him; Tantawi got his money from the same pocket. The state believes that we are swallowing the lies they feed us, but we're not."

Morsi-supporter Samir Amin Ibrahim, 30, said the news of Mubarak's "death" worried him as he felt it was part of a military-organised plan. "It is like everything is scheduled to ensure the revolution is killed, first the parliament is dissolved, then Shafiq is allowed to run for the presidency, then the SCAF's constitutional declaration and now Mubarak dead, just when we take to the streets in big numbers."

However, he added that if Mubarak had died, people would be still be unhappy, despite ousting the former president "we don't rejoice in death."

Some, like shoe seller Ashraf Mohamed Youssef, 36, thought that it is an elaborate ruse to ensure that Mubarak is moved out of Tora Prison and into the comfortable surroundings of the Maadi Military Hospital. Mubarak, who had served just 18 days of his life sentence, initially refused to enter Tora Prison after being found guilty on the 2 June of participating in the crime of killing protesters during last year's popular uprising.

Previously he had been living in the luxury of the International Medical Centre, which, allegedly, had gardens, a swimming pool and a helicopter pad.

Youssef worries that Mubarak's death will garner support for the 84-year-old autocrat "people will feel for sorry for him, he's an old sick man, we are human after all." 

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

Hesham Agag
21-06-2012 02:53am
What about those
What about those behind bars for political reasons,many of them are very sick Why the media hightlight the news of an ousted dictator. Many fell victims under torture of Mubarak 's security personals. Yet few were punsihed for their criminal actions
Comment's Title

20-06-2012 10:30am
Clean the tahrir
The SCAF are VERY patient!!!!! If i could i clean the square from the dirty that gather there with more brutality than old regime can do. They dont represent the egyptian, revolutionerys. We have to end with Muslim Brootherhood like we did with Mubarak.
Comment's Title
Henrica Von Kile
21-06-2012 03:35am
my comment is that MB id the least of your problems
meaning, you got Al Qaida... Hamas... Hizbulla... Moslim Brotherhood... the list of filth you have to clean is endless... it has come to define you... well... you are Ugly... really ugly
Hesham Agag
21-06-2012 02:57am
Clean your mouth first
clean your mouth first, Who do you represent?,Shurley u representing Shafq and Old generals

20-06-2012 06:18am
Dictator of a brutal regime..... Hell, if I was the leader of a country, I might resort to violence to quell an uprising. It doesn't seem THAT weird to me. You gotta keep things together or people go crazy. I don't know a whole lot about Hasni, but from my view here in the USA, he didn't seem like a brutal dictator, and I always found him a quite likeable character.
Comment's Title
Hesham Agag
21-06-2012 03:01am
Hitler has got fans.Franco has got fans. Every dictator was admired by scum like you because all flock fly togther
20-06-2012 08:47am
You're an idiot
Why the hell are you commenting when you clearly know NOTHING about the situation? For 15, maybe 20 years, Mubarak kept peace and brought in money. Brutality was probably needed then. But when he starts jailing Ayman Nour for being democratic or torturing those who just want a less corrupt Egypt, he lost it. Although, he's been so ill for the last 10 years, I doubt he was much more than a figurehead. A figurehead guessed it...SCAF.
20-06-2012 06:42am
To FrenkO
If you spoke out against him he would have you arrested and tortured to death (not just him but his cronies). He left but his cronies miss feeling invincible. Back in the day if they liked a lady and she was married they would force the husband to divorce her and force her to marry them. They were ****. (This was before Mubarak's time, but same regime) Trust me! They Put all the "hated US presidents" to shame.
	WorldCup 2018- News, Live score, Groups, Teams, Matches and stats-Ahram Online

© 2010 Ahram Online.