Last Update 22:51
Tuesday, 15 October 2019

Choice of new PM Hisham Qandil divides Egypt's political class

President Morsi's appointment of little-known former irrigation minister Hisham Qandil as new prime minister proves controversial with politicians, activists

Ahram Online , Tuesday 24 Jul 2012
Hisham Kandil
Egyptian minister of water resources and irrigation in the outgoing, military-appointed government, Hisham Kandil poses for a portrait in Cairo (Photo: AP)
Views: 7026
Views: 7026

President Mohamed Morsi's decision on Tuesday to appoint Hisham Qandil as Egypt's new prime minister has provoked mixed reactions from the country's politicians and activists.

A former irrigation minister in the post-revolution governments of Esam Sharaf and Kamal El-Ganzouri, Qandil is not formally affiliated with any Egyptian political parties or groups.

Mostafa El-Naggar, a liberal MP in the dissolved People's Assembly (the lower house of Egypt's parliament), told Ahram Online that it was too early to judge the appointment.

"We need to know the standards by which Qandil was chosen. We need to know his record, his history and performance in previous positions," El-Naggar said.

He criticised those who were already judging the new prime minister based on his Islamist background.

Independent activist Ahmed Imam, who is amongst those calling for a united front with Morsi to counter the military's influence in politics, said he did not have a view on the new prime minister.

"I still do not know anything about Qandil and therefore I cannot judge," he said.

Several political figures and activists, including Imam, declared their support for Morsi upon his electoral win in June after he confirmed Brotherhood members would not form the majority in his new government.

Leftist activist Wael Khalil, who joined the united front and was nominated for Morsi's presidential team, told Ahram Online it was too early to judge Qandil.

"I can't trust those who praise him or those who attack him so soon," said Khalil.

However, Khalil was more critical of the way Qandil was appointed than the choice itself.

"We need to know the criteria by which Qandil was chosen. We need more transparency."

Morsi should be transparent or "he will be following in Mubarak's footsteps, who took sudden and shocking decisions without providing explanations," Khalil added.

"Egyptians should know Morsi's plan and whether he aims to achieve national unity or merely implement the Brotherhood's renaissance programme," he concluded.

On the other hand, Essam Shiha of the liberal Wafd Party criticised Morsi's appointment of Qandil because the president had promised to appoint a non-Islamist as prime minister.

Moreover, Shiha said Egypt needs an economic expert in such a position, a qualification which Qandil lacks.

The Wafd Party had refused to accept any posts in a Morsi government because it wanted it to be composed only of Brotherhood members so the people could more clearly assess its performance, Shiha said.

The best alternative, according to Shiha, would be for Morsi to appoint a government of technocrats.

Qandil in fact proposed a government of technocrats after his appointment as premier.

On a more positive note, liberal youth activist Esraa Abdel-Fatah said via Twitter:

"Thank God Hisham Qandil is young and we are now seeing a prime minister in his late 40s."

Khaled Said, spokesperson for the Salafist Front, said via Twitter:

"A young government is better than an elderly one. Successful negotiations with Nile Basin countries and meeting the demands of protesters at the irrigation ministry are amongst the achievements of Hisham Qandil."

Saad El-Hosainy of the Freedom and Justice Party (FJP) told Ikhwan Online that his party backed Morsi's choice of Qandil as prime minister.

"The FJP will cooperate with the prime minister and the new government to help them accomplish their mission," El-Hosainy said.

The FJP, the political arm of the Muslim Brotherhood, is expected to hold 30 to 50 per cent of the positions in the new government, while the Brotherhood's deputy leader Khairat El-Shater is expected to hold the economic portfolio and become deputy prime minister, according to media reports.

President Morsi was widely criticised for taking too long to form a new government after his inauguration on 30 June.

Several names had been proposed as potential prime ministers, including former head of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Mohamed ElBaradei, former Egyptian Social Democratic Party MP Ziad Bahaaeddin, central bank chief Mahmoud Abul-Eyoun and former minister and member of the Egyptian Social Democratic Party Hazem El-Beblawi. All have denied they were offered the position.

This article has been amended. It had erroneously referred to Mostafa El-Naggar as a 'former Muslim Brotherhood MP'  in a previous version.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

26-07-2012 11:24am
Let's wait and see!!
Mr Morsi is the current president and therefore he is entitle to choose his own cabinet including the Prime Minister. I am sure that Mr.Morsi knows very well that he will live or die in a political sense by this decision! So let's wait and see before starting praising or criticising the new prime minister
Comment's Title

25-07-2012 01:52am
reply to hector
This is what is wrong with Egypt today... Small minded bigots like yourself... if ML says he is Muslim, Then he is Muslim! Who are you to say what religion he is or is not? TL is entitled to his view on Egypt just as we all are, why take the view to call him a liar? Even i (and yes i am Muslim!) am not with this whole " MB" ideology, thats my choice.. if you don't like my view.. Tough luck!
Comment's Title

24-07-2012 11:30pm
Choice of new PM Hisham Kandil divides Egypt's political class
The real problem with Egypt today is scaf. The president & PM won't add up to much until scaf is dismantled and generals are put on trials.
Comment's Title

24-07-2012 07:27pm
Egyptians,Wake Up !
I am a Moslem and I am less than 60, does that qualify me to run the government? This is a puppet PM appointed by a puppet president. Both have no credentials to run Egypt with it's current economic,political,social and religious challenges. To the people that say don't judge and wait to see what they will do, I say Wake Up. If we let these incompetents run the country, by the time we see the results, the disaster will have happened. We are like lambs being led to slaughter !
Comment's Title
25-07-2012 10:40pm
Too late
The cards (carefully mixed by the US and MB) have already fallen into their places proper and as one of the commentators (m ali) said "Egyptians are too tired for another revolution". Egypt is finished, becoming the Islamic Republic of the Muslim Brotherhood in no time - and for good!
25-07-2012 04:19pm
Choice of new PM Hisham Kandil divides Egypt's political class
The electorates who cared to vote decided who they want for president this time. This is how democracy works. Next time round they are free to choose another. Meanwhile, you need to hold back. Surely, this is superior to what you were having for the past 3000+ years of servitude and had patience to wait..
25-07-2012 05:50am
Hector -
Hector. I am a Muslim and I love my Christian and Jewish brothers. I love all of Humanity. There are no conspiracies here.
24-07-2012 10:37pm
go back to sleep!
stop talking rubbish. secularist had your chance under mubarak and egypt remained a third world country. now lets see if this new gov takes egypt to the next level
m ali
24-07-2012 09:53pm
what are you going to do
u are saying if we let those incomp.....what do you suggest egyptians do, another revolution is impossible egyptians are tired
Hector M
24-07-2012 09:27pm
Reply to TH
TH, your statement of calling yourself Moslem tells me your are a Copt.

© 2010 Ahram Online.