Last Update 23:17
Hundreds of thousands besiege Egypt's presidential palace to protest draft constitution
Demonstrators take to streets nationwide to protest Egypt's draft constitution less than two weeks before referendum on proposed national charter
Yasmine Fathy, Randa Ali and Zeinab El-Guindi, Tuesday 4 Dec 2012
Share/Bookmark
Views: 2986
Hundreds of thousands go out against draft constitution
Egyptian protesters demonstrate outside the presidential palace in Cairo, December 4, 2012 (Photo: Reuters)

Hundreds of thousands of protesters gathered at Egypt's presidential palace and in Tahrir Square Tuesday to protest a draft constitution and a recent decree by President Mohamed Morsi giving him sweeping powers.

"This constitution is all wrong. It violates freedoms and was only created by the Brotherhood and Salafists for their own benefit," said Hanan Sabri, a housewife, as she walked to Tahrir Square, the site of mass protests against the recently issued draft constitution.

The Constituent Assembly, which wrote the draft charter, is accused of having been dominated by the Muslim Brotherhood – from which President Morsi hails – and Salafist groups. The assembly has also been marred by several withdrawals, including by representatives of the Coptic Church, labourers, journalists and farmers.

The draft constitution itself is seen by critics as unrepresentative of Egyptians at large and as falling short on the freedoms and social benefits called for in the 25 January Revolution. Many articles are also criticised for being vague.

"There is an article that states that society should be 'self-critical.' What does that mean? It means that we’ll find people bothering us for not liking what we wear," added Sabri.

The draft constitution was rushed through in a final marathon session during which it was approved by assembly members, cutting short an additional two-month period set aside for discussion of its contents. Morsi was then presented with the document, after which he announced it would be put to a nationwide referendum on 15 December.

Thousands gathered in Tahrir Square on Tuesday while hundreds of thousands made their way to the presidential palace in Cairo's Heliopolis district to voice opposition to the draft charter.

Two major marches from the Abassiya and Madinet Nasr districts close to Heliopolis brought the bulk of protests to the door of the palace. Another rally from Ain Shams University merged with a rally from Rabaa Al-Adawaiya.

The marches began at 4pm and maintained a peaceful nature, with protesters chanting 'Down with Morsi, down with the rule of the Supreme Guide,' as they snaked through the streets leading to the palace.

Amany Moussa – walking in the Madinet Nasr rally, which was launched from the Rabaa El Adaweya Mosque – complained that Egypt had finally seen some stability in recent months, but Morsi’s constitutional decree had again led to violence.

Before a date for the constitutional referendum was set, the president had issued a constitutional declaration that shields his decisions from judicial oversight and protects the Constituent Assembly and Shura Council from dissolution by court order.

The declaration was deemed "dictatorial" by the opposition, which filled Tahrir Square twice in protests last week.

Islamist forces then held a rival protest on Saturday in defence of Morsi's decree. Dubbed the "Day of Legitimacy and Sharia," hundreds of thousands of Islamists gathered at Cairo University to back the president.

"I know he's an elected president, but I think he lost his legitimacy," Moussa said.

"There are various articles in the constitution that violate the values of the Egyptian revolution, especially articles allowing civilians to be put on trial in military courts," she said.

"This is the first time I join a protest," Ahmed Ibrahim, another protester at the rally, told Ahram Online. "I am so angry, I feel that the Muslim Brotherhood are dominating everything and taking complete control of the country."

Participating in the Abassiya march that set out from Cairo's Al-Nour Mosque, Shaimaa – an independent activist in her twenties – travelled from Suez to join the march to denounce Morsi's constitutional declaration.

"We are here to attend the protest; we’ve taken part in all major protests happening in Cairo since the 25 January Revolution," she said, as she arrived with thousands of others in the vicinity of the presidential palace.

Like Ibrahim, Shaimaa condemned the recently finalised draft constitution as being "a constitution made only for the Muslim Brotherhood."

Shaimaa added that she came only to protest peacefully, but intended to stay if any protesters were assaulted.

As protesters reached the presidential palace, they were met with a cordon of barbed wire and security personnel. A few minutes later, teargas was fired from the security side, although soldiers later retreated, opening the way in Merghany Street for protesters to pass.

As they approached the main gate, protesters chanted, "The people want to topple the regime," and, "We will not leave, he will leave."

"Down with the Supreme Guide [of the Muslim Brotherhood]," they yelled, while waving Egyptian flags and banners that read: "We reject splitting the country in two using religion," and, "We reject the constitutional declaration."

Protesters also waved flags bearing the images of slain protesters, including Sheikh Emad Effat – who died during clashes between military police and protesters during a December 2011 sit-in – and Sayid Belal, a Salafist activist tortured to death in 2010 under the ousted Mubarak regime.

Challenges face the looming constitutional referendum, as Egypt's Judges Club announced it would boycott the poll – and refrain from supervising polling stations as it usually does – to protest what it calls Morsi's "power grab" decree, which they say impinges on its independence.

In reaction to the Judges Club stance, Egypt's Supreme Judicial Council announced on Monday that it would allocate judges and members of the prosecution to supervise the referendum despite the strike action.

Tuesday evening also witnessed protests in Alexandria, Mansoura, Mahalla, Hurghada, Luxor, Assiut, Minya and Ismailia against the draft constitution and constitutional declaration. According to activists, thousands of protesters took the streets in huge rallies in Alexandria.





Short link:

 

Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 4000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.
6



Parvez Ahmed
05-12-2012 09:40pm
1-
0+
Embarrassment for consciuosness
All the Islamist is someway blindfolded in every country. Definitely they are more honest but somehow they think they are the part of the creator and has a tendency to overlook and respect others opinion. The decree has damaged Muslim Brother-hoods reputation that they have earned for years with their honesty and integrity. They need to be more respectful to others’ opinion even if that is expressed by the minority. Islamist must be mindful that religion is for the humanity rather humanity is for the religion.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
5



Thabo
05-12-2012 11:21am
2-
6+
Very difficult to understand.......
This protest by the opposition is very difficult to understand!! Egyptians has a chance to voice their opposition to the constitution via a referendum on 15 December 2012 but here the Opposition is behaving like thugs on the street bent on violence and disorder. Seems to me that a greater force is behind this opposition protest like the hand of zionist israel who thrive on disorder in their neighbouring arab countries.....
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
4



shakeel
05-12-2012 08:40am
2-
5+
Hardly tens of thousands
Sir, please don't over estimate the size of the crowds while even international media is estimating the crowds are in tens of thousands u r putting it as hundreds of thousands speak truth fear the God and change the headline to tens of thousands
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
3



deen
05-12-2012 03:00am
1-
6+
wrong estimation
where you find hundred of thousand protesters you must be very weak in counting
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
2



Modern_Humaniora
05-12-2012 12:43am
1-
5+
If they care about Egypt ...
Moussa, Elbaradei and Sabbahi have only one option left - if they care about Egypt's stability and future. They have to tell their followers that the only option left is to vote on the draft Constitution. It's only the people of Egypt that can, by vote, solve this non-consent. A constitution isn't a static device. That's the bargain to strike up with.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
1



Charlie Cousins
05-12-2012 12:19am
0-
2+
Diversity is a difficult beast to domesticate, but one that can carry any burden
Please allow a comment from an outsider. The homogenization of governments, whether representing a majority of the governed population or not, creates classes of citizens subject to enforced authority without benefit of active representation. Each part of a blade is required for it to fulfill its designed purpose. The iron that dictates its structure, the carbon that gives birth to hardness, the nickel that allows the blade to sing as it flexes to resist cracking under pressure. Which part is most important? Which part can be eliminated and yet allow the blade to fulfill its purpose in the way it was intended? None. It is true there are many voices, each with its own timbre and cry, that encompass the Egyptian people. The work is in learning compromise. And the art is in sculpting a whole from EACH of its parts that reflects the soul of the people and the glory of the nation. No man, or woman, is an island. I am a foreigner and I side with John Donne, but to ask for wh
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment

© 2010 Ahram Online. Advertising