Last Update 18:23

Citing violations, Egyptian rights groups demand new charter poll

Human rights groups call for rerun of first phase of constitutional referendum due to 'numerous' violations witnessed during voting on Saturday

Randa Ali , Sunday 16 Dec 2012
Views: 1895
Press Conference
Press conference by rights groups against violations that took place during the constitution referendum, 16 December (Photo: Randa Ali)

A number of prominent human rights groups have called for a re-run of the first phase of Egypt's constitutional referendum due to numerous violations reported during polling on Saturday.

"Despite the revolution, we had a referendum like those held during the Mubarak era," Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies (CIHRS) leader Bahi El-Din Hassan said at a press conference on Sunday.

Hassan went on to list several types of violations that "invalidate the whole [referendum] process."

For example, there were cases of 'fake' judges overseeing the voting at polling stations.

He also accused several judges of closing polling stations early despite an order by the Supreme Electoral Commission (SEC) to extend voting until 11pm.

Human rights lawyer Negad El-Borai added that members of civil society organisations were banned from entering polling stations. However, members the Freedom and Justice Party were given permits to enter polling stations and sometimes used that access to encourage people to vote 'Yes'.

"We have reported all the violations, but there has been no response from the SEC," added El-Borai, who questioned how the SEC could release statements denying violations had occurred without investigating them.

El-Borai added that the violations were serious enough to invalidate the referendum and reminded both Hossam El-Gheriany and Ahmed Mekki, who were part of the Judges intifada of 2005, that they had earlier said any "flaw" in the electoral process made it invalid.

Judge El-Gheriany was head of the Constituent Assembly that drafted the constitution, while Judge Mekki was appointed justice minister by President Mohamed Morsi on 12 August.

Furthermore, El-Borai accused El-Gheriany, who also heads the National Council for Human Rights, of giving more than 20,000 election-monitoring permits to members of the Freedom and Justice Party.

"It is for the commission's own good to admit its failure to properly organise the referendum and to call for a re-run," he said.

El-Borai asserted that no matter what the result was, the referendum should be void.

Human rights lawyer and Shayfenkom (We are watching you) member Ragia Omran said the group's hotline had received thousands of calls about violations during the referendum.

"More than 3,000 reports of violations were filed by citizens, not from monitors," said Omran, who added that many police reports were filed to complain about the lack of judges inside polling stations.

A protest organised by Shayfenkom will take place on Sunday at 8pm in front of the SEC headquarters to denounce the polling violations.

Meanwhile, Appropriate Communication Techniques for Development (ACT) director Azza Kamel said her group had received around 4,000 reports of violations, including 1,400 official reports about "huge violations."

Kamel also complained of "deliberate delays" at women's voting stations, especially in Cairo and Alexandria, aimed at hindering voters.

All the activists and lawyers present at the press conference demanded a re-run of the first phase of the referendum, saying further action would be decided upon after a response had been received from the SEC.

Those present said complaints would be sent to the prosecutor-general and demanded the justice minister form a delegation of judges to investigate reports of violations as soon as possible.

"The manipulation of the people's will did not start [on Saturday]; it started with the formation of a Constituent Assembly dominated by one current," CIHRS leader Bahi El-Din Hassan added.

Almost half of Egypt's governorates voted on the constitution on Saturday. Preliminary results suggest 56.5 per cent voted 'Yes'.

The second phase of the referendum is scheduled to take place on 22 December.

Short link:


Comment's Title
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 50 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

Freedom Fighter, Aladdin
18-12-2012 05:09am
Nothing New
Lying is great sin in Islam; guess who is lying thru his teeth? Thanks AO for defending liberty.
Comment's Title

16-12-2012 07:03pm
unfair process.
The oppositions have flooded the media with a negative campaign against the constitution from day one. If this constitution were to have a fair explanation we would have a 90% yes vote. This more about the ego of the oppositions more than the fairness.
Comment's Title

mohammed moiduddin
16-12-2012 07:02pm
Why I am not surprised about asking for a rerun?
I thought it would be Larry Moe and Curly but its not. There were enough judges or not blame a group that should not be political, be independent, and not be boycotting. They failed Egypt. To be honest I hope they never ever get their jobs back. Time complete reform of the system. Its the JUDGES, Its the JUDGES there are no checks and balances on them. They need to quit. THey are all mubarak appointed.
Comment's Title

16-12-2012 06:37pm
shame again
the last statement attributed to the CIHRS leader show their protestaionhas nothing to do with the polls integrity. it just that these opposition are sore losers. we're quickly finding out that the Islamists are the best democrats in Egypt!!
Comment's Title

16-12-2012 06:21pm
Oh God
Another election?. Oh please not another election. It seems that election results that favor islamist don`t count. Or that the electorate are forced to repeat elections over and over until Baradai is President?. Every week an election. Have much fun.
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online. Advertising