Last Update 9:5
Tuesday, 23 October 2018

Islamists tighten grip on Egypt's Shura Council

The upper house of parliament (Shura Council) is scheduled to convene on Wednesday, with Islamists tightening their grip on its ranks

Gamal Essam El-Din , Tuesday 25 Dec 2012
Shura Council
Shura council (Photo:Al-Ahram)
Views: 5817
Views: 5817

The Islamist-dominated upper house of parliament (Shura Council) is due to hold two procedural meetings on Wednesday in preparation for a new parliamentary season after assuming legislative power for the first time in 32 years.

The Shura Council, which was protected from dissolution by a controversial presidential decree last month, will have the legislative authority until a new lower house of parliament is elected within two months after 64% of Egyptians approved the new constitution, according to unofficial results.

The Council was set up by late president Anwar El-Sadat in1980 as a consultative body. It also had control over state-owned press organisations.

The first opening meeting will see 90 members – officially appointed by Islamist president Mohamed Morsi – take the constitutional oath. The Council’s speaker Ahmed Fahmi, a member of the Muslim Brotherhood’s Freedom and Justice Party (FJP) and a relative of President Morsi, will deliver a speech which will be followed by a statement from Prime Minister Hisham Qandil on the country’s deteriorating economic conditions.

There has been much speculation recently over whether Qandil’s government will be fired or just reshuffled. Rumours are rife that the government will be forced to resign to make way for a new cabinet headed by business tycoon and influential Brotherhood leader Khairat El-Shater.

A number of senior FJP officials, such as Essam El-Erian, have repeatedly criticised Qandil’s government and openly called for the appointment of El-Shater as a new prime minister to take charge of implementing Morsi’s so-called “Nahda” (Renaissance) project.

The second procedural meeting will be devoted to completing the make-up of the Council’s 11 committees. The internal regulations of the Council will be amended to give it the power of legislation in accordance with article 230 of the newly-passed constitution.

The article also states that a new Shura Council shall be elected within a year after the lower house of parliament (House of Representatives) is elected. It will include 150 members, tenth of whom will be appointed by the president.

The Shura Council currently includes 270 members, 90 of whom were appointed by President Morsi on 24 December.

As expected, the Muslim Brotherhood, from which Morsi hails, and its Islamist allies dominated the list of the 90 appointees. The Brotherhood’s allies include the two main Salafist political parties – the Nour and Gamaa Islamiya (Islamic Group) - and the moderate Islamist party Al-Wassat.

Many members of the three Islamist parties took part in the constitution-drafting process.

The list of the appointees also included several independents who were members of the constituent assembly that was tasked with writing the constitution.

“The Shura Council has once again become a hotbed for regime loyalists, just like it was under (former president) Hosni Mubarak. This time it’s loyal to the Muslim Brotherhood and its sycophants,” political analyst Gamal Zahran told Ahram Online.

“The list of appointees clearly shows that the Muslim Brotherhood, like Mubarak, puts loyalty first when selecting figures for appointment in political institutions like the Shura Council.”

Islamist members

All in all, the number of Islamist appointees stood at 42, 17 of whom belong to Muslim Brotherhood. The list of appointees also included 19 Islamist-oriented independents (5 of whom belong to Al-Azhar, Egypt’s highest religious authority).

Topping the list of appointees are six high-profile officials of the Brotherhood’s FJP, including  Essam El-Erian (chairman of the outgoing parliament’s Foreign Relations Committee); Sobhi Saleh (the deputy chairman of the outgoing parliament’s Legislative Affairs Committee); and Ashraf  Badreddin (deputy chairman of the outgoing parliament’s Budget Committee).

Other Brotherhood-affiliated members include Gamal Heshmat, Abbas Abdel-Aziz Khaled, Abdel-Qader Auda (a senior Brotherhood ideologue) and Khairi Abdel-Dayem (chairman of the Doctors’ Syndicate).

The list also includes some firebrand Salafists such as Amir Bassam; Mohamed Youssri; Mohamed El-Saghir, Mohamed Omran, Mohamed Badawi, and Safwat Abdel-Ghani, who was convicted of killing former speaker of parliament Rifaat Al-Mahgoub in 1990.

Surprisingly, the list featured Abdel-Hadi Al-Qasabi, a former senior official of Mubrak’s defunct National Democratic Party (NDP).

El-Qasabi was a member of the NDP’s policies committee, which was led by Mubarak’s younger son Gamal. He was appointed by Morsi although article 232 of the constitution bans the senior NDP officials from engaging in any political activity for ten years.

Reports suggested that Al-Qasabi was appointed in return for his efforts to coax Sufi groups into voting “yes” for the constitution.

The list also included Fadiya Salem, a former NDP official in Sinai and a current member of the liberal-oriented Reform and Development party, which is headed by late president Sadat’s nephew.

Some little-known secular political parties, which refused to withdraw from the constituent assembly, also had representatives in the Shura Council. On top of these are Ghad El-Thawra (the Revolution’s Tomorrow) party, which is led by political activist Ayman Nour. The list includes Mohamed Mohieddin and Abdel-Moneim El-Tunsi, who were members of the constituent assembly.

Constitutional law professors Gamal Gibriel (a law professor and chairman of the constitution-drafting assembly’s system of governance committee), Hamed Hassan (a member of the mini-committee which took charge of putting the final draft of the constitution), Ramadan Batikh and Maged Ragheb El-Hilaw (two constitutional law professors) were present in the list of appointees.

Al-Azhar clerics also got their quota of seats in Shura Council as Hassan El-Shafie (an assistant to Grand Imam of Al-Azhar) and Nasr Farid Wassel (the former Grand Mufti of Egypt), who were active members of the constitution-drafting assembly, were picked in the Council..

Al-Wassat party, an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, earned four seats. Those include the party’s secretary-general Mohamed Abdel-Latif, spokesman Tarek El-Malt, professor Amany Qandil and activist Tarek El-Mahdi.

Al-Wassat Party actively cooperated with the Muslim Brotherhood in drafting the constitution. In return, the party’s leading official Mohamed Mahsoub was appointed minister of state for parliamentary affairs last July.

The election of the Council last February saw the Brotherhood's FJP win 103 seats (around 58.5 per cent) and the Salafist Nour Party gain 44 seats (25.5 per cent) of the total 180 elected seats. This gives Islamists the largest share with around 84 per cent of the total elected seats.

The list of appointees increased the Brotherhood and Salafist seats to 180 (or two thirds of the seats), out of 270. Following the addition of 40 appointed and elected independents with Islamist leanings, the majority of political Islam members will go up to almost 220 members (or around 75 per cent of total elected and appointed seats).

A number of secular parties and independents were able to clinch around 50 seats during last February’s Council elections.

The new list also includes eight political parties which got one seat each; and around 14 independents, 12 of which are Christians, including Catholic businessman Rami Lakah, political science professor Mona Makram Ebeid, political analyst Sameh Fawzi, lawyers Mamdouh Ramzi and Suzi Nashed, and political activist Nelly Fam Naguib.

Critics fear Islamists would try to pass laws aimed at tightening their grip on power such as regulating street protests, which have been on the rise since Morsi assumed power last June.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

26-12-2012 05:31am
western backed secular minority
Egypts western backed secular minority is trying to be potrayed as politically oppressed. They are trying to set an image as a firm advocate who are being stuck into a corner, while they have a large support. In order to do this they are rejecting offers to participate in the government. and to be active in rebuilding the country. The whole world knows that the large majority of egyptians support the islamic ideology of rule. I am not from Egypt but i pray for a leader like Dr.Mursi. and for parties like FJP and al nour. no matter how much difference of opinion they have among them. the goal is the same. that goal is the goal of every muslim. Egypts leaders should be prepared to lead the entire islamic world. build ties between other leaders of the muslims who are working for the goal. i pray that the establishment of the goal would be very soon.
Comment's Title

26-12-2012 04:34am
Why complaint now?
The liberals has lost. Since the beginning they have decided to abandon Egypt - by not participating in drafting the constitution, by rejecting the referendum, by clinging to smear campaigns, by cooperating with the Mubarak remnants/felols. Besides, why complaint about the legitimate choice of Egyptian for an Islamic flavor of governance? They have done their work, they deserve it. Now why liberals keep talking and giving no contributions to the beloved country? Why???
Comment's Title

26-12-2012 04:24am
pay attention to the numbers. They don't lie
How could you say the Majority(64%)of Egyptian when in fact only a third of the voters(17 Million) turned out. it means that the 64% is actually 20% ONLY. The Egyptian population is 83 million in Egypt and 12 million abroad. What happened to all the rest of Egyptian, at least the remainig 65 million in Egypt alone. So Please pay attention to the numbers
Comment's Title
27-12-2012 10:31pm
and now what?
The don`t have voted NO. So what is your point again.

26-12-2012 02:31am
One sided article
The author is trying to impose a negative view of the president the MB on the readers, which is not reasonable and not compatible with journalistic ethics.
Comment's Title

25-12-2012 10:50pm
its not true that most of those selected by the president were from the brotherhoos. in fact the vast majority were not islamists at all.
Comment's Title

shafey danish
25-12-2012 07:52pm
Pls dont blame the MB
"Tens of liberal and leftist figures have declined the positions offered to them by the president in the Shura Council." Dont blame the brotherhood if the ratio is skewed. They won elections, and when the president invited secular figures they did not join.
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.