Last Update 19:8
Thursday, 19 April 2018

Brotherhood fortress turns hotbed for protests as Morsi sidelined

Fresh protests in Egypt make light of President Mohamed Morsi’s rule, directing anger towards the Muslim Brotherhood and its leader

Hatem Maher, Monday 18 Mar 2013
Muslim Brotherhood
One of the Muslim Brotherhood's offices in Cairo (Photo: Reuters)
Views: 3926
Views: 3926

On Saturday, two passengers on Cairo's underground metro in their early 20s looked jaded, but they still shouted at the top of their voices, demanding an end to the “rule of the Supreme Guide.”

Calling him names, the two men went on a foul-mouthed outburst against Mohamed Badie, the man they believe had overruled Egypt’s elected President Mohamed Morsi and assumed effective control of the country.

The passengers, it transpired, were angry because they had been involved in a confrontation with Brotherhood members in front of the Islamist group’s headquarters in the Cairo district of Mokattam, a fortress that has long been spared street violence and attacks.

The presidential palace was a protest hotspot for several months, but it has now made way for the Brotherhood's Cairo headquarters, a building that lies on a hill which overlooks many parts of Cairo, in a reflection of the opposition's belief that Morsi is largely subordinate to Brotherhood leader Badie, who keeps a low profile despite being the subject of constant speculation about his actual role in Egypt.

Badie, who was elected as the Brotherhood Supreme Guide in January 2010, one year before the eruption of the revolution which eventually propelled his once-banned group to power, is now under the spotlight more than ever.

The 69-year-old had to deal with an unusual situation when he was heckled by a young man while dining with his family at a fancy Cairo shopping centre last week.

The man furiously questioned his role, but Badie simply replied, according to a Brotherhood spokesman: “If I'm the one who actually rules Egypt, then I agree with you: ‘Down with the rule of the Supreme Guide’.”

Perhaps Badie has something to prove to some disgruntled political activists, who seem to have almost forgotten Morsi in their chants, preferring to hurl a barrage of insults at a man they believe is more influential in the unofficial ruling hierarchy.

‘Morsi not ruling Egypt’

Clashes erupted at the Brotherhood headquarters when protesters sought to mark it with graffiti, spray-painting murals that condemned the group and its leader.

Deeming the act “provocative,” Brotherhood members rushed out to confront protesters, using wooden sticks to disperse them.

Images and footage of a well-built man aggressively slapping a woman in the face went viral on social networks, drawing a chorus of denunciation.

“Some youths besieged us after we drew the graffiti and hurled obscenity-laced insults against us … one of them hit me hard on the face and we had to retreat after finding out that they held bladed weapons,” activist Mervat Moussa, the woman slapped by a Brotherhood member, told satellite television channel ONTV.

 “We will continue to fight until we bring down the rule of the Supreme Guide, because Mohamed Morsi is not the one ruling Egypt.”

Several journalists said they were also attacked and dozens were injured when police stepped in.

Media phone-ins were rife with anti-Brotherhood rhetoric that questioned the group’s legitimacy in comments not heard since the era of deposed leader Hosni Mubarak, whose iron fist kept at bay the 85-year-old group until a revolution ignited by the youth brought them to the forefront of politics.

The group remains legally unrecognised, but several Brotherhood officials said recently its status will be legalised once a new law regulating the establishment of NGOs is put into effect.

Brotherhood-Morsi relationship

Critics of Islamist movements feared Egypt would turn into an Iran-style hierarchy in which the president is overpowered by a cleric. They believe their fears were realised, at least partly, nine months after Morsi became the country’s first freely elected leader.

The Brotherhood and its political arm, the Freedom and Justice Party (FJP), consistently distance themselves from the presidency. Morsi resigned his membership of the FJP upon winning the presidential elections in 2012.

“In fact, all rumours about the intervention of the Muslim Brotherhood in government affairs have no basis in truth, and are totally unacceptable,” said Brotherhood secretary general Mahmoud Hussein.

Morsi was coy when he was asked in a recent television interview about his relationship with the Brotherhood and its leader, saying that his “historical links” with the Brotherhood have a big influence on him but that he is now the president of all Egyptians.

Critics accuse him of only caring about the Brotherhood's interests, citing his decision to dismiss interior minister Ahmed Gamal El-Deen because he failed to protect FJP bureaus during recent nationwide clashes as an example.

He was also criticised for allowing an Islamist-dominated Constituent Assembly to fast-track Egypt’s first post-revolution constitution late last year.

“Morsi is a helpless president who cannot make any decisions. He simply follows the instructions of the Brotherhood Supreme Guide,” well-known writer Alaa El-Aswany, who supported Morsi in last year’s presidential elections but later became one of his staunchest opponents, wrote in his column in Al-Masry Al-Youm newspaper.

“Morsi is the one who ruined his relationship with Egyptians … the millions who poured into the streets to celebrate his success in the elections are now calling for an end to the Supreme Guide's rule.”

Demonstrators called for more protests in front of the Brotherhood headquarters, which is now protected by armoured police vehicles, over the next few days.

Meanwhile, one of the two train passengers asked his friend whether there was any chance Morsi would turn against the Brotherhood one day; his comrade responded with derisive laughter.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

19-03-2013 11:56pm
The mastermind
Badie by his comments is also deriding the President, probably a throw away line! The MBs make many inflaming statements and actions along with the other Islamists, and they are never condemned or even addressed by Dr Morsi. It is also well known that the MB edited Morsi's 'early' morning speech, once a Brother always a Brother, this is the only part of history that Dr Morsi seems to remember. Does anyone remember the Muslim Brotherhood's 'Renaissance project, one of the main reasons many voted for Morsi! He has lost all credibility with the Egyptians, so many failed policies, now they are blaming the Brotherhood who they consider to be the 'key' and mastermind of our crisis.
Comment's Title

18-03-2013 03:11pm
Conflict resolution through violence __ end game.
Egypt media has not see the other side, the Islamists, taken to the street. if liberals insist on escalation, the other side will get violent. Media has role to calm down this manufactured tension. If we slip into Somalia's model, all of us will lose. This is a scenario that external enemies are hoping for.
Comment's Title

Jason Gregson
18-03-2013 09:54am
A time for progree
Stop working all together and bankrupt the country, let the fat politicians go on a no food diet. Ditch the Jesuits and get rid of them. The canal access is not for sale, it's passage is for the countries who do business and have the interests and country at heart. You do not have to be best friends to do business. But good business does not thrive on oppression the legitimate people. Save the history, preserve the culture and all sites. You do not need handouts, many hundred of billions exist and will show up as the people earn it. And no debt, cherish your families and teach the traditions that have preserved the people through times. The media makes the enemies most of the world is not enemies. People want to exist and live not be fighting, bullshit is bullshit but living is living. Lots of oil other than Saudi. No debt at all or loans, do it all on your own.
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.