Last Update 22:6
Friday, 18 October 2019

Campaign to issue new Egypt constitution gathers different momentum

Political forces to ask president to change 8 July declaration so that it calls for writing new constitution rather than amending 2012 version

Gamal Essam Eldin, Tuesday 24 Sep 2013
The 50-member committee
The 50-member committee (Photo: Al-Ahram)
Views: 3370
Views: 3370

Representatives of liberal and leftist forces serving on the 50-member constitutional committee said on Monday that they will launch a "public opinion" campaign to ask that interim President Adly Mansour change his constitutional declaration issued on 8 July.

The liberal representatives are calling on Mansour to modify his 8 July declaration so that the 50-member constitutional committee is tasked with writing an entirely new constitution, rather than simply amending the 2012 version drafted by an Islamist-dominated constituent assembly.

Article 28 of Mansour's July constitutional declaration originally gave the 50-member committee a mandate to amend the now-suspended 2012 constitution.

According to Mahmoud Badr, a founder of the Tamarod (Rebel) movement that spearheaded the 3 July removal of Islamist president Mohamed Morsi, his group, in addition to other political forces, are in the process of opening communication channels with President Mansour to address the issue.

"In order to close the door to any appeals that might be filed against the legality of the current constitution-drafting process, we ask that interim President Mansour change his 8 July constitutional declaration so that when citizens go to vote in a national referendum they know that they are voting on a new constitution, rather than an amended one," Badr said on Monday during an address to the National Dialogue sub-committee and female representatives of the National Council for Women (NCW).

Badr's remarks came after a number of NCW activists declared that "the 2012 constitution must be radically changed, especially with regards to those religious articles that discriminate against women."

Sekina Fouad, a high-profile writer, echoed Badr's call, saying "as an advisor who is very close to President Mansour, I and others plan to ask him to change his 8 July constitutional declaration."

"President Mansour is above all a man of law, and he is aware of the necessity to amend the declaration in order to protect against possible appeals regarding the legality of amending the 2012 constitution," Fouad added.

Fouad argued that although the 50-member committee is in the process of changing the 2012 constitution "as a whole," a new declaration is needed to support these efforts.

According to Fouad, the 2012 constitution is a religiously-oriented national charter.

"Islamist forces began turning Egypt into a religious state shortly after Egyptians revolted against the former regime of Hosni Mubarak in 2011

"When Egyptians were asked to vote on a constitutional declaration in March 2011 calling for parliamentary elections ahead of constitution writing, Islamists took the matter as a battle between believers – those who voted 'yes' – and infidels – those who voted 'no'," said Fouad, adding that "this division has ultimately led up to the promulgation of a religious constitution in 2012."

Also joining the fray, National Dialogue sub-committee and lawyers syndicate chairman Sameh Ashour argued that "when Egyptians turned out in the millions on 30 June, they were revolting against the regime of Muslim Brotherhood, its constitution, and its president."

Ashour indicated that the subcommittee would launch a "public opinion" campaign to convince Mansour of the change. Pointing to a survey conducted by the subcommittee, Ashour said that representatives from several sectors of society strongly support an outright ban on the formation of religious parties, in addition to the elimination of Article 219 and other "Islamist" articles.

"We need to write a new constitution, not just polish the image of the 2012 version," said Ashour.

According to deputy chairperson Mona Zulficar, the 50-member committee worked on some significant changes to the constitution this week. In particular, Zulficar says Article Three, which gives "Christians and Jews the right to exercise their religious rites," will most likely be changed to give all non-Muslims the right to practice.

Article Three currently states that "For Egyptian Christians and Jews, the principles of their religious law will be the main source in regulating their personal status, matters pertaining to their religion, and the selection of their spiritual leadership." If amended, the article will begin with "For all Egyptian non-Muslims."

Zulficar also indicated that most members are in favor of amending Article One to state that Egypt is a civilian state.

"The word "civil" is important to stress, for Egypt is neither a religious state, nor it is governed by a religious or military state," said Zulficar, adding that a "civil state" also means that "state authorities are not above the law and that the state is governed by the rule of the law."

Zulficar explained that while Al-Azhar, Egypt's leading institution for Sunni scholarship, proposed changing Article One to say that "Egypt is a civil constitutional state," the ultraconservative Nour party rejected the word "civil."

Zulficar stressed that Egypt as a "civil" state necessarily entails the banning of religious political parties.

"Political parties are established to obtain power by peaceful means, and not to exercise religious activities," she argued.

Zulficar pointed out that Article 54 of the new constitution drafted by the initial 10-member technical committee stresses that "Political parties cannot be established on religious foundations."

According to Zulficar, this article lacks the necessary teeth to guarantee that parties are not formed on a religious basis.

However, Zulficar believes that once the constitution is passed, new legislation "designed to regulate the performance of political parties and ensure that they do not perform religious activities" will impose the necessary measures to "help religious parties adjust themselves to get in line with Article 54, or face dissolution." 

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

27-09-2013 06:00pm
Whose Constitution Is This?
The constitutional draft document by 50 hand picked people can be the most beautiful and the best document on this earth but it only reflects the wishes of the elites who dominate the drafting committee. The Egyptians across the country are not represented and as such will be tantamount to forcing it into their throats. We have to recognize that the wishes of the majority in the first instance must prevail despite it not being equivalent to that of the western democracies nor not being palatable to the elites of Egypt. The document will then undergo democratic evolution as the country moves forward. While the coup regime talks about returning the country to democracy, the Constitution which will be the supreme law of the nation and the basic foundation to the Egypt's Democracy is being written by dictators. Every practice of the coup regime is non democratic. Sorry!!! Egypt will not have democracy in this manner. looks like Egypt needs another coup by democratic minded generals who aspire a free and democratic Egypt for future generation.
Comment's Title

24-09-2013 02:58pm
Whole world laughing when they watching Egyptian news. because Egyptian coup politic become a very big joke for the whole world force govt want do any thing as he like ..from army to court every one going on his own way ,,and public looking high way . but still there sisi .. road is block
Comment's Title
24-09-2013 09:23pm
laughing? really?
@JOHN, if that is really your name..You have got it all wrong..the only thing the people of the world are laughing at is the mb & their inability to take responisibility for their actions & what they caused. I am starting to think that the mb, morsi & their supporters either can not think for themselves or just plain do not have the brain to think for themselves. If they could not see that the majority of Egyptians did not want them in power any more than they are delusional.

24-09-2013 10:39am
Amending a constitution would be like mending a torn dress. Don’t the Egyptian people deserve better than that? Write it anew! Btw., before the referendum on Mursi’s 2012 Islamist constitution, Mr. El-Baradei and his (Hisb el-Dostour) party members said they had already drafted an alternative constitution (including a bill of rights). Where is that draft? And another thing: Why does the constitutional committee not include Egypt’s most renowned constitutional expert, Mr. Ibrahim Darwish (who advised other countries on how to write their constitution)? Why is he being left out? In my opinion, the constitution should also pay respect to all the international treaties (human rights, civil rights, women’s and childrens’ rights, etc) Egypt is signatory too. It should also include “freedom of religion”, so that religion cannot be abused for political purposes again.
Comment's Title

Ramy the Egyptian
24-09-2013 02:51am
New Constitution
These people are clearly competent and know very well what they're talking about. Writing a new civil non-religious constitution will be the absolute sign that the revolution has succeeded, both revolutions...
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.