Last Update 13:4
Friday, 18 October 2019

Monday evening sees rally for Mohamed Mahmoud victims

In Cairo's Abdeen Square, activists and demonstrators commemorate protesters killed by police during two years of clashes in Mohamed Mahmoud Street

Osman El Sharnoubi, Monday 18 Nov 2013
Protesters gather at Abdeen Square in commemoration of Mohamed Mahmoud clashes, (Photo: Mai Shahin).
Views: 1670
Views: 1670

Activists gathered on Monday to commemorate the second anniversary of the 2011 Mohamed Mahmoud Street clashes when dozens of protesters were killed by police.

The demonstration was held one day before the actual anniversary of the beginning of the clashes, as activists planning the event were keen to avoid the involvement of the Muslim Brotherhood, who had said they would stage rallies to honour the slain protesters.

During Monday’s demonstration, which took place in Cairo’s Abdeen Square in the capital’s downtown, activists chanted against the Supreme Council of Armed Forces (SCAF), which was ruling at the time of the clashes, and demanded retribution for the "martyrs" who were killed.

They also chanted against the Brotherhood, who at the time of the clashes had denounced those protesting.

A stage was erected in the square, and on it activists roused the crowds yelling: "the people demand the execution of the field marshal," referring to the retired SCAF leader Mohamed Hussein Tantawi, while insisting that they don’t share a cause with the Brotherhood.

"We’re not Brotherhood, nor do we want [ousted president Mohamed] Morsi," the crowd chanted, differentiating themselves from the group and its main demand so far.

Egypt’s major non-Islamist parties, including the liberal Constitution Party, the Egyptian Social Democratic Party and the Socialist Popular Alliance Party, took part in Monday’s demonstration and said they will not take part in Tuesday’s protests.

Fearing the anniversary would be "used" by others for political ends, the Constitution Party warned its members against attempts to "create a rift" between the people and the army and called for them to remain peaceful and make national security as a priority.

Similar fears were expressed by other activists, who said they were protesting on Monday instead of Tuesday was due to their belief the anniversary of the 2011 clashes may be "appropriated by state or Muslim Brotherhood forces to serve their respective interests."

"The Salafists and the Brotherhood said they will protest on Tuesday and so did pro-military groups. Today’s protest was planned to avoid becoming part of clashes between both, we don’t want to be implicated in blood in case there are clashes," prominent leftist activist and former presidential candidate Khaled Ali told Ahram Online while attending the demo.

"Tuesday’s protests don’t represent our battle, it will be a fight between those aligned with the military and the Brotherhood and that’s why we chose to commemorate the events today," Ahmed Naguib, member of the "Martyr Gaber Salah Movement," a group named after Gaber "Jika" Salah, who lived in Abdeen and was killed by police last year on the clashes' first anniversary, told Ahram Online.

Salah was the first protester to be killed by police during Morsi’s time in office, and was the most prominent "martyr" visible in Abdeen Square. A flag carrying Jika’s face, painted in black against a white background, was the largest of several flags bearing faces of others killed by police.

"Our group will launch a series of events in the honour of Mohamed Mahmoud’s martyrs. One of them will be a bill to restructure the interior ministry which we will present to the government," Naguib said.

Talking from the main stage, prominent activist and physician Ahmed Harara spoke about the need to rehabilitate the interior ministry.

"We revolted because we saw policemen act as thugs. This garbage can of an institution must be purged," he told the crowd.

Harara lost both his eyes after being injured by birdshot fired by police, one in the January 2011 uprising against Mubarak, the other in Mohamed Mahmoud clashes in November 2011.

He stressed that the police must be held accountable by an independent entity, not by police officers or prosecutors whom he accused of covering up the former's crimes.

Similarly, leftist activist Mohamed Waked addressed the protesters, saying that the interior ministry is the main base of the current political system.

Waked argued that people were gathered not to passively commemorate the previous year’s martyrs, but to insist that the situation must change.

"We mustn’t make our future hostage to our fear of a group. What is happening to them now will happen to us in the future if the ministry of interior isn’t reformed," he stated, referring to the Muslim Brotherhood, many of its top leaders now detained.

Forty-seven protesters were killed in the 2011 clashes and the government of then prime minister Essam Sharaf resigned, replaced by a cabinet headed by Mubarak-era prime minister Kamal El-Ganzouri.

Three - including Jika - were killed in the 2012 Mohamed Mahmoud anniversary clashes.

"There was no retribution; police officers are now dancing. Those who escaped after the 2011 revolution have returned," Amal Shaker, mother of protester Ahmed Zein El-Abedein, killed in the 2011 uprising against Mubarak, told Ahram Online.

The Way of the Revolution Front, an anti-military, anti-Brotherhood group, is planning to commemorate the anniversary of Mohamed Mahmoud with a march on the street on Tuesday evening.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

Samantha Criscione
19-11-2013 09:21am
Why all the attacks on security forces? Because they are successfully investigating terror disguised as protest
Mohamed Waked, a so-called 'leftist' (I say 'so-called' because the term leftist is now used as a label for all sorts of people who don't care a bit about the working class) is quoted as saying, "What is happening to them [i.e., to the Brotherhood] now will happen to us in the future if the ministry of interior isn’t reformed." Since what is happening to Brotherhood leaders is that the ministry of interior investigates their crimes committed while pretending to be peaceful protesters, and then they are being put on trial for those crimes, does that mean that Waked and his associates a) oppose prosecuting the Brotherhood clerical fascist murderers for their very real crimes and b) that they have committed such crimes, falsely presented as 'protest,' themselves -- for example, burning down the National Council for Women building in January 2011 -- and/or wish to commit such crimes in the future? And regarding this demand to 'reform' the security apparatus, which in the current situation means to prevent it from uncovering Brotherhood crimes and the links between the so-called 'moderate' Brotherhood and open terrorists, it occurs to me that, considering that Lieutenant Colonel Mohamed Mabrouk was assassinated just before all these demonstrations attacking the police, that the assassination was carried out to send a message to officials: give in to the demands to 'reform' the security forces, meaning, stop them from investigating the campaign of terror conducted by the Brotherhood, which is supported by foreign (Turkey, EU, Iran, U.S.) enablers, or this will happen to you. -- Samantha Criscione
Comment's Title

© 2010 Ahram Online.