Last Update 21:7
Sunday, 22 September 2019

Ending this war begins with recognising Hamas: Carter, Robinson

The Elders members Jimmy Carter and Mary Robinson weigh in on what they see as a 'humanitarian catastrophe' in Gaza

Ahram Online , Wednesday 6 Aug 2014
Jimmy Carter and Mary Robinson
Jimmy Carter (L) and Mary Robinson (R) (Photo: Reuters)
Views: 1549
Views: 1549

In an article published on Foreign Policy's website, former presidents of the United States and Ireland – Jimmy Carter and Mary Robinson – called for the recognition of Hamas as a "legitimate political actor" to end the Israeli war on Gaza.

The article, entitled "How to Fix It”, blamed Israel's rejection of the new Palestinian unity government announced last April as a "deliberate obstruction of a promising move towards peace in the region" has caused the ongoing "tragedy."

Both world leaders believed that Hamas made a "major concession" in the decision to open Gaza to be governed by a technocratic government that did not include any members of the Islamist group.

"Tragically, Israel rejected this opportunity for peace and has succeeded in preventing the new government's deployment in Gaza," Carter and Robinson, also a former UN Human Rights commissioner, said.

The former presidents, who are members of The Elders – an independent group of global leaders who describe themselves as seekers for "peace and human rights" – urged lifting of the seven-year-old sanctions and blockade that isolate the 1.8 million people in Gaza.

 "There must also be an opportunity for the teachers, police, and welfare and health workers on the Hamas payroll to be paid. These necessary requirements for a human standard of living continue to be denied," they said.

They also stated that there is "no humane or legal justification" for the way Israel conducts this war, noting that bombs, missiles, and artillery have "pulverised" large parts of Gaza including thousands of homes, schools and hospitals.

Speaking to the lost access to water and electricity in the strip, Carter and Robinson stated that the situation of Gazans is a "humanitarian catastrophe" and called on the UN Security Council to limit the potential use of force by both sides.

"Ultimately, lasting peace depends on the creation of a Palestinian state next to Israel", the article claimed.

Carter received the Nobel Peace Prize in 2002 for his decades of tireless effort to find peaceful solutions to international conflicts, primarily exemplified by brokering the Camp David Accords between Egypt and Israel on September 1978.

The peace treaty was the first of its kind between Israel and an Arab state. Egypt's President Anwar Sadat and Israel's premier Menachem Begin were also awarded a Nobel Peace Prize in 1978.

However, Carter faced fierce criticism by pro-Israeli groups in 2007 for his book "Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid." In the book, the former US president slammed Israeli policies towards the Palestinians including the erection of separation wall in the West Bank, comparing Israel to apartheid South Africa.

Egypt brokered a 72-hour truce on Tuesday between Israel and Hamas-led Palestinian factions, a step within ongoing Cairo talks over a durable ceasefire.

Israeli ground forces withdrew from the Gaza Strip ahead of the truce, with a military spokesperson saying the main goal of destroying cross-border infiltration tunnels had been achieved, Reuters reported.

The Israeli war on Gaza has led to the death of 1,875 Palestinians since it began on 8 July.

On the Israeli side 64 soldiers and three civilians have been killed in clashes and shelling in and around the enclave.

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

06-08-2014 11:53pm
Might be nice for Hamas to recognize Israel's right to exist before we recognize Hamas as a "legitimate political actor." Shame on you Mr. Carter
Comment's Title
13-08-2014 07:41pm
someone comes to your house pointing his gun and orders you and your family to get out, you can't take any personal belongings, you have 3minutes to leave. Then when you and your family are out in night gowns, you are told to recognise the house belongs to Him.

Samantha Criscione
06-08-2014 07:31pm
Concerning Carter's Horrible Proposal
If this were just a case of a private citizen in love with clerical fascism, it would be irrelevant. The problem is, Carter is an established stalking horse for the U.S. government. -- Samantha Criscione
Comment's Title
Andrew A
06-08-2014 11:32pm
Jimmy Carter is America's Worst Ex-President
President Carter is a pariah to American foreign policy and foreign relations with long-standing allies. This man, a failed President, has been trying desperately to legitimize his place in American history since he left office. He is a trouble-maker with a world-view that can be taken seriously only in fantasy. Is is a further testament to the illegitimacy of the Nobel Peace Prize that he is an award winner.

Homer Jones
06-08-2014 04:26pm
Whaddya think?
What do you think about Carter ordering a legitimised Hamas on your border, my Egyptian friends?
Comment's Title
06-08-2014 09:18pm
Humanity,shame,freedom of speech,freedom of expression and assembly,respect for difference of opinion, right to opposition all these words,symbols,expressions have been vanished in Egyptian society after 3rd July 2013 when Egyptians put their heads in the gutter.Now an autocrate general is standing on their heads not allowing them to get out of it.
Sam Enslow
06-08-2014 05:23pm
Carter ordered?
When did Carter ORDER anything? He is a private citizen expressing his view. Why imply otherwise?
06-08-2014 05:13pm
Ooh those mean old Hamas, terrorist guys!
When will you Egyptians ever learn? This is much more than Hamas, Israel, Hesbollah, etc. It's about humanity! If you Egyptians would get your heads out of the gutter for once and realize that the world stands in solidarity with the 1.8 million civilians in Gaza! Personally speaking, i do not care about Hamas and/or Israel! I care about freedom for all!

© 2010 Ahram Online.