Last Update 11:18

Hamas slams Abbas' anti-right of return statement

President Mahmoud Abbas tells Israeli TV he has no permanent claim on the town from which he spent his boyhood, raising questions and criticisms about his position towards the Palestinian right of return

Reuters, MENA , Friday 2 Nov 2012
Views: 780
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas (Photo: Reuters)

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas made a concession to Israel on Thursday, saying he had no ownership on the town from which he was driven out of as a child during the 1948 war of the Jewish state's founding.

Among several disputes deadlocking Middle East peace talks has been the Palestinians' demand that as many as five million Palestinians be granted the right to return to lands in Israel that they or their kin lost.

Israel rules this out, fearing an influx of Arabs that would eliminate its Jewish majority, and argues the refugees should resettle in a future Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip; territories it occupied in the 1967 war.

Speaking to the top-rated Israeli television newscast, Channel 2, Abbas was asked whether he wanted to live in Safed, his childhood town in the Galilee region of what had been British-ruled Palestine and is now northern Israel.

"I visited Safed before once. But I want to see Safed. It's my right to see it, but not to live there," Abbas told Channel 2, speaking in English from the West Bank city of Ramallah.

"Palestine now for me is '67 borders, with East Jerusalem as its capital. This is now and forever ... This is Palestine for me. I am (a) refugee, but I am living in Ramallah. I believe that (the) West Bank and Gaza is Palestine and the other parts (are) Israel."

Abbas has defied Israel and the United States by planning to ask the UN General Assembly to upgrade the Palestinians to a non-member state. Facing possible punitive Israeli and US sanctions, Abbas has promised an immediate return to peace talks after the UN vote, which the Palestinians are likely to win.

The televised remarks, which were excoriated by Abbas's Palestinian Islamist rivals, also appeared aimed at influencing Israelis ahead of their 22 January legislative election.

Polls currently predict an easy win for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, a rightist who says he wants to restart talks with Abbas but who has championed Jewish settlement of East Jerusalem and the West Bank - the reason the Palestinians gave for breaking off the last round of negotiations in 2010.

"No Third Armed Intifidada"

Some Netanyahu government officials have voiced scepticism about Abbas's ability to deliver a peace accord, after he lost control of Gaza - from which Israel withdrew in 2005 - to Hamas Islamists in a brief civil war two years later.

On Channel 2, Abbas sought to play up his security control over Palestinian-run areas of the West Bank, saying that as long as he was in power "there will no armed, third armed Intifada (revolt against Israel). Never."

"We don't want to use terror. We don't want to use force. We don't want to use weapons. We want to use diplomacy. We want to use politics. We want to use negotiations. We want to use peaceful resistance. That's it."

Netanyahu's office had no immediate comment on the interview, which was aired as the prime minister returned from a visit to France. Israel has long blamed Abbas for the stalled diplomacy, saying his insistence it freeze settlements - which are widely viewed as illegal abroad - amounted to preconditions.

Paul Hirschson, a spokesman for Israel's Foreign Ministry, said the onus remained on Abbas to return to negotiations:

"If he (Abbas) wants to see Safed, or anywhere else in Israel, for that matter, we would happily show him anywhere. But there has to be a desire to move forward on the peace process."

As Abbas is not an Israeli citizen, Hirschson added, "He doesn't have a right to live in Israel. We agree on that."

Secret Palestinian memoranda leaked to the media last year showed that Abbas had, during talks with the previous, centrist Israeli government, been willing to concede on some core demands - including by accepting a cap on refugees admitted to Israel.

Under Netanyahu, Israel has campaigned for the hundreds of thousands of Jews who it took in from Arab countries after the 1948 war to be recognised as refugees, proposing they be seen as a demographic counter-balance to dispossessed Palestinians.

Hamas Response

In Gaza, Hamas denounced Abbas, saying he spoke only for himself. The Islamist movement does not recognise Israel and has regularly exchanged fire with it.

"No Palestinian would accept ceding the right of our people to return to homes, villages and towns from which they were displaced," said Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri.

"If Abu Mazen (Abbas) does not want Safed, Safed would be honoured not to host people like him."

 Izzat al-Rishq, member of the Islamist movement's Political Bureau, pointed out that no one has to take a decision about the right of the Palestinians refugees to return to their homeland without their consent.

"The Palestinian territory is not exposed to compromise or negotiation; Abbas is speaking about himself only," he said.

The Spokesman of the Hamas government in Gaza Taher El-Nounou ironically said that the statement of Abbas makes no difference than the 1917 Balfour Declaration, adding that Abbas "takes advantage" of every opportunity to grant legitimacy to Israel and express his opposition to the concept of armed resistance.

"If we revised the words of Abbas and the Balfour Declaration, we'll find both moving in notable consistency," El-Nounou stated.

Short link:


Comment's Title
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 50 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

Aladdin, Egypt
03-11-2012 04:45am
Smart Move
You are great poltician. Please do not certify that Israel is a Jewish state until they act like one.We have wonderful relationshipo with our home-rown jewish people for thousands of years not with the Euro-zionists.
Comment's Title

02-11-2012 07:24pm
Abbas is a weak and coward man and the fraction of Palestinians who are supporting him or keeping as their leader are no more than collaborators with the Zionist criminals.
Comment's Title

02-11-2012 05:01pm
Abbas is a traitor he has no other choice than to be Israel's puppet.
Comment's Title
A woman
05-11-2012 01:27pm
Maybe Abu Mazen is just more realistic than other ones... Palestinians are not the first ones in history and in the world who have to live with deportion and who have to accept the status quo. There are so many cases like this all over the world. Palestinians should stop to see themselves always just in the role of the victims. That's no good "investment" in the future. There are millions of deported people all around the world who never will have the chance to return to their homelands.. I don't say this to justify Israelian politics....
04-11-2012 08:53pm
Abbas: A second Balfour Declaration. What a Traitor! He will be rebembered as the Palestinian Lord Balfour!

© 2010 Ahram Online. Advertising