Last Update 20:53
Thursday, 14 November 2019

Egypt: Banning Salafist Nour Party may backfire

Before advocating a ban of Islamists, non-Islamists need to heal their internal rifts to gain more support among conservative Egyptians

Nervana Mahmoud , Sunday 30 Aug 2015
Views: 3470
Views: 3470

A popular campaign in Egypt has been launched advocating the disbanding of religiously oriented parties. The campaign started generating support and has already gathered 4,000 signatures.

The movement is now backed by Egypt's Ministry of Endowments that released an official statement in support of the campaign. Meanwhile, a religious Salafi leader, Sameh Abdel-Hamid, is calling for the dissolution of "liberal" parties, which he considers “unconstitutional.”

In his opinion, they advocate the separation between the religious and the state, and accept “Western-style freedom,” which would allow gay marriage in Egypt.

The brewing tension between non-Islamist and Islamists camps is not surprising, particularly as both sides are gearing-up for the upcoming parliamentary elections.

The tension between Islamists and non-Islamists within the 30 June bloc that backed the ouster of the Muslim Brotherhood’s President Morsi in 2013 is not new.

They bickered considerably about the Egyptian constitution until they reached compromise, albeit non-secular, language. The preamble of the 2014 Constitution affirms that, “The principles of Islamic Sharia are the principal source of legislation, and that the reference for the interpretation of such principles lies in the body of the relevant Supreme Constitutional Court rulings.”

Article 74 of the constitution, meanwhile prohibits the establishment of parties on a religious basis. Nonetheless, last July, Egypt’s Supreme Administrative Court upheld an earlier verdict in which it turned down a petition demanding the dissolution of the Nour Party.

For its part, the Nour Party frequently reiterates that it does not adopt a religious reference and stresses its identity as a political party open to members of all faiths, including Copts, a matter that alarms the Coptic Church in Egypt.

Non-Islamists in Egypt have a strong case based on Article 74 of the constitution to campaign against religiously-based parties such as the Salafist Nour Party.

The Nour Party may have reinvented its look and opened membership to Copts, but it is still a hard-core political Islamist party. Non-Islamists are right to reject the mixing of religion with politics that has infested Egypt’s political life for decades.

They are also entitled to expose Islamists’ ugly propaganda against liberalism and their deliberate blurring of the differences between liberalism and decadence.

Nonetheless, the campaign to ban religiously-based parties may not succeed, and may even misfire.

On the one hand, imposing a hasty ban against the already squeezed Islamist movements will only trigger sympathy and victimhood among their traditional supporters, who already fear alienation and marginalisation.

On the other hand, the election law allocates the majority of seats in the coming parliament to independents, a move that may allow not just Salafists, but also the Muslim Brotherhood — as individuals — to win seats in the next parliament as independents. Major General Refaat Komsan, election affairs advisor to Prime Minister Ibrahim Mahlab, said in an interview that his committee cannot stop certain factions, presumably including the Muslim Brotherhood, from joining this year’s parliamentary elections.

Furthermore, many non-Islamist parties, including Wafd and Dostour, are marred by internal struggles that may impede their chances of success in the next election. Therefore, any ban on Islamist parties will not necessarily translate to votes for already unpopular, unconvincing non-Islamist parties; and instead it may only trigger apathy and low turnout among their core supporters.

Before advocating a ban of Islamists, non-Islamists in Egypt should first do their groundwork. They need to articulate a clearer vision that grasps what and how non-Islamism can work in Egypt and how it can appeal to the apolitical public. Blurring Islam and Islamism is one of the powerful weapons employed by political Islamists.

Non-Islamists, regardless of their political affiliation should unite to demystify that blurred image to the naturally conservative Egyptian public. They also need to educate the public about liberalism and secularism and how those concepts are not anti-Islam as political Islamists like to propagate. This battle is crucial in the quest to reclaim the soul of Egypt.

In short, Egypt needs to uproot Islamism organically; not via the pesticides of formal bans.

The popular campaign against religiously oriented parties may offer a good opportunity to raise awareness about the pitfalls of political Islam, and may improve the electoral culture in Egypt.

A formal ban of political Islamist parties, however, is not a healthy way forward. Non-Islamists need first to heal their internal rifts to stand a better chance of gaining more support among conservative Egyptians. It is a long road, but the campaign trails of the next parliamentary election could be a good start.

Nervana Mahmoud is a doctor, commentator and writer on Middle East issues. 

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

03-09-2015 10:02pm
Reclaiming the soul of Egypt!
The choice between Islamist parties or Secular Parties is a diversion from the fact that ALL these parties are frankly useless. The choice should be based on which Party(s) has an economic plan and expertise to rebuild Egypt; what investment policies, what industry sectors to build, how to eradicate poverty, how to educate our kids to join the 21 century, how to “reclaim the soul of Egypt” as you put it. If the Pickering is all about “how long the beard is” vs. “legalizing gay marriage” there is no chance in hell these parties would accomplish anything for the next 100 years. Who care about Sharia vs. Western liberalism if the population is growing by 3% a year, Nominal GDP is only 3%, and Inflation is 10% … Bankruptcy and Cannibalism is 5 years away and we are worried about fake forehead zebibas and dress codes for singers? Let’s get real, enough with the minutiae!
Comment's Title

01-09-2015 04:17pm
uproot Islamism
"Egypt needs to uproot Islamism organically; not via the pesticides of formal bans" this only can be wish and dream of the liberals,secularis,copts and the Junta,but this will remain a wish and a dream.Islam & Islamism is an integral part of the Egyptian society.
Comment's Title
Nervana Mahmoud
02-09-2015 11:22pm
Islam is not Islamism
Blurring Islam with Islamism is ugly and wrong. No one can uproot a faith, but mixing religion with politics is demonising Islam

Sam Enslow
01-09-2015 09:25am
Final court ruling
Regardless of the legal status or not of the Nour party, a final legal ruling should be obtained from the highest court involved before the Parliamentary elections because either position unless validated by the courts could render the elections invalid/unconstitutional.
Comment's Title
14-09-2015 05:35pm
Egypt can never have democracy as long as those Kangaroo courts exist
Those corrupt courts are cancer for civilized world.

© 2010 Ahram Online.