Last Update 11:20
Sunday, 20 October 2019

The cultural challenges of the Syrian refugee crisis

Beyond the dangers of arriving to safety, refugees face ongoing challenges that can come to define their lives, centred around their integration into, or alienation from, their new host societies

Nervana Mahmoud , Thursday 17 Sep 2015
Views: 20479
Views: 20479

When refugees embark on the dangerous, often deadly, trip towards Europe, many of them are consciously aware that the price of settling in the Western world will include accepting different laws and ways of life.

The challenge of cultural differences, however, may not be a pressing issue for those desperate to survive the savagery of war zones.

Nonetheless, it is an essential part of what will shape their future success in their adoptive countries. Without a brave and honest assessment of the question of culture, those “lucky” refugees may not just be potential victims of racism and hatred; they could face an unsettling, unhappy future.

Historically, the dynamic of cultural expectations has always been reduced by both sides, the new settlers and the welcoming nations, to a few shallow cultural differences over relatively trivial aspects such as food habits and the exposure or concealment of women’s flesh. It is not.

The cultural divide involves far deeper issues, ranging from the subtlety of body language and eye contact to more overt actions, such as engaging with the local community and developing a sense of belonging.

“Miss Mahmoud, you are now a registered alien,” the female police officer with a masked face told me after giving me my police registration certificate. I was not a refugee or an asylum seeker. Still, I had to register with the police like all foreigners in the United Kingdom.

For months afterwards, the word “alien” preoccupied my thoughts. Although I was told it is a legal term that has nothing to do with ethnic, cultural, or religious differences, I still could not help but wonder how alien I would be in Britain.

I have always considered myself an Anglophile. I learned English at a very young age, read Shakespeare, Charles Dickens, W Somerset Maugham, and the Brontë family, and have listened to the BBC service religiously since my teenage years. None of these experiences has made my settlement in England easier.

Living in a country is a completely different experience than just reading a few books and watching a few programmes. Yes, I was alien, and I found England an alien place.

This sense of alienation eased off gradually, but only because I refused to remain alien. That does not mean I betrayed my native values and faith. Far from it, but I learned to weave them smoothly within the new fabric of my new society.

It is paramount to understand that the reasons and circumstances that compel anyone to move to a new country will only have short-term impacts on his/her future.

Those reasons will gradually become irrelevant to future success or failure; a part of the narratives that will always be recited in the past tense. The language barrier will also be solved in time.

The core issue for long-term survival and success, however, is the degree of alienation an immigrant feels in his/her newly adoptive community, and what he/she is willing to do to minimise it.

For every newcomer, the challenge is to strike a delicate balance between his/her own culture and the one of the adoptive country. This balance is tricky and may be difficult to achieve, but it is rewarding and offers long-term dividends.

First, it is important to understand that culture has never been a static phenomenon. The customs and social behaviour of a particular people or society are constantly changing.

Historically, Muslims in Andalucía were more cosmopolitan and more culturally open than other Muslim societies. In the modern era, cultures vary considerably in many Muslim countries. Customs and ways of life in Pakistan are different to those in Egypt, and both are different to the customs in Yemen, and so on. Even within the same countries, cultures have changed remarkably in recent decades.

The Middle East experienced a liberal era in the middle of the 20th century. For example, at the time, it was perfectly acceptable in many Muslim countries for women to uncover their hair, wear swimming costumes, and ride bikes.

Understanding the chronology of cultural diversity of one’s native country is the first step towards success in any host nation, as it protects against resenting or dismissing the local culture.

Second, there are big differences between Islam as a faith and Islam as a culture. Every Muslim society has its own traditions that some people wrongly consider as part of the faith.

For example, many male Muslims refuse to shake the hands of women (and vice versa). However, it is well known that Imam Abu-Hanifa, one of the founders of Islamic jurisdiction, sanctioned handshaking between men and women. Such a basic human greeting can build bridges between settling refugees and their local neighbours.

One article recounts the feelings of a female Syrian refugee in Brazil who has to explain why she doesn’t shake hands so people won’t get upset. Clearly, the practice is not right for her. The woman also feels awkward at the Brazilian tendency to hug each other. She admits that her greatest lament is loneliness.

This is not surprising, for if someone opts to embrace the strictest interpretation of Islam instead of the most lenient one, then disengagement from society and loneliness will indeed follow.

Islam as a faith has many liberal aspects that can help Muslims settling in Europe. It accepts diversity, welcomes non-Muslims, and tolerates non-practicing Muslims.

That was once the norm in many former Muslim societies, in Baghdad and Cordoba, and should be reinvigorated now among those newcomers to Europe.

Third, Muslims do not have to drink alcohol, eat pork, or change their dress code to fit in with the local community. Attitude is the core issue; not faith-related issues.

Another interesting story, this time from America, concerns a Muslim flight attendant who was suspended “for refusing to serve alcohol.” Charee Stanley, a Detroit-based flight attendant for ExpressJet, who filed a discrimination complaint, was not an immigrant, but a recent convert to Islam. Any newcomer to a Western country desperate to find a job could land up in a similar dilemma if the job involved serving alcohol.

The problem here is the flight attendant’s wrong expectations: she expected her colleagues to accept the extra work burden. Although the Muslim flight attendant had every right to refuse to serve alcohol, she should have sought a different job that did not include serving alcohol, instead of expecting her colleagues to bail her out.

It may be fair to describe those refugees who have been warmly welcomed in Germany as “lucky.” After all, they survived deadly cross-continental journeys to reach their destination. Nonetheless, this luck will not last, unless it is coupled with genuine efforts by them and their adoptive countries to help their integration in their local societies. Some of those refugees may try to “transplant” their native culture into their new homes and communities.

That approach may appear easier in the short term, but they will only achieve long-term success in their adoptive countries if they accept culture as a dynamic, evolving concept, and dig deeper within their faith for more liberal values that helped their ancestors to flourish in old Western communities such as Andalusia. Dogma and myopic conservatism will not help the refugees settling in Europe.

The writer is a doctor, commentator and writer on Middle East issues.You can follow her on twitter @Nervana_1

Short link:


Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.

19-09-2015 09:29am
one thing or two..
1. forget about "welcomned" refugees, this is only governmental soap opera,non german has been asked untill today,if they WANT to host millions of stranger syrians. 2. IF those try to implement their culture or habits in germany, civil war will break loose, because GERMANY has a society and population,here is no space for "new" settlers, in fact its one of the most dense populated countries in the world.... better wake up and get real instead of dreaming! get your own nation back on the road and build it up!
Comment's Title
26-09-2015 01:02pm
You are right Western fascists are happy when Zionists from Europe implement their culture and steal land
They only have problem when Muslims seek refuge for normal life.

18-09-2015 02:55am
Success or failure depends on the new immigrants
I have lived in UK, Canada and USA as an immigrant. I succeed in all 3 countries because I believed that you have to work twice as hard to be equal to them and you will. I worked hard to learn their traditions, the language so I can communicate. I watch many Immigrants over the years. Those that are unable to learn the language, use it to learn from locals, their traditions will always feel that they do not belong there. However those that quickly learn the language and use it to ask and learn the local culture will eventually feel that you belong there. You don't have to do everything they do. You can say that I don't do this or that because of my religion or believes will be accepted for that. Other side have to understand why you don't do this or that and I found d that they always accept and respect that. So work hard on learning and participate in local community as much as you can and you will be part of it which will make you "happy at home'
Comment's Title
Aly Sadek -Toronto-Canada
18-09-2015 07:56pm
YES...100% right... " RESPECT AND TRUST" the two easiest things in life for someone to lose and the hardest things to get back. While goodness and hard work are rewarded with respect and exceptance . My experience ..after 45 years in beautiful Canada.... Montreal...Vancouver... Toronto.e

© 2010 Ahram Online.