Last Update 23:3
The tragic fate of Sinai's dual-nationals
An irrational executive decision issued by the government of Hisham Qandil under the rubric of "comprehensive development" of Sinai is set to ruin thousands as well as Sinai
Nabil Shawkat , Tuesday 20 Nov 2012
Share/Bookmark
Views: 7487

Sinai used to be a land of equal opportunity, a place where people went to start a new life, to get away from the crowded Nile Valley, to escape the tensions of big cities, to avoid the country's widespread joblessness and to try something new. For some, moving to Sinai was a way to connect with the country of their origin. It was a place where expatriates enjoyed retirement, and children of mixed marriages felt at home. No more!

As of two months ago, Sinai is off limits for investors with dual nationalities, and also for Egyptians who have one foreign parent. Forget that Sinai was already a beleaguered territory, a place about which tourists think twice before visiting, because of political tensions involving Hamas and Israel, murderous attacks by freelance jihadists, and random abductions by disgruntled Bedouins.

The recent assault on Sinai came from a much higher authority: the government of Hisham Qandil.

In mid-September, the current government issued executive regulations requiring Egyptians with dual nationalities to sell their homes, lands, and businesses within six month. That is to say, by next April Sinai will be rid of, not the Jihadists, not Israeli threats, not its multiple financial woes, but rid of hundreds of Egyptian families. Sinai may also lose billions of dollars as a result of the rush to sell property in an already depressed market.

The government's decision, which received little or no coverage in the media, has caused widespread panic among investors in Sinai. Hundreds of lawsuits are likely to be filed against the government within weeks, according to business sources in Dahab and Sharm El Sheikh.

The text of Article 8 of the Executive Regulations for Law 14 for the Comprehensive Development of the Sinai Peninsula, which caused all the turmoil, appeared in the Official Gazette (issue 210) on 13 September 2012. Here is a translation of this text:

"An Egyptian who has obtained another nationality and kept his Egyptian nationality has to sell his property, be it land or buildings, in the Sinai Peninsula to Egyptians who hold solely the Egyptian nationality and whose parents are both Egyptian within six months of implementing these executive regulations. If the six months elapse without the property thus sold, the ownership of the property shall devolve to the state in return for the payment of equivalent (compensation) price to the owner. The (compensation) price is to be decided by a committee of experts the formation and task of which is to be determined in a decision to be issued by the minister of justice."

What this means is that hundreds of Egyptian families of dual nationality, people who have lived in Sinai for twenty or thirty years, people who own small and large businesses, whose children were most likely born in Sinai, will have to sell their land, their homes, their businesses at any price they can get, within the next four months.

The executive regulations were issued in September, but the Sinai local community didn't learn about them until two weeks ago and only by chance. There have been no notifications, no official letters, not even a distant whisper, before the axe fell.

Who, I wonder, has the money to buy this property worth billions of dollars? And what kind of financial and emotional damage is being inflicted on those Egyptian families whose only sin was to trust in their country's ability to respect ownership?

It is ironic that these ruinous executive regulations were affiliated with a law promising to create "comprehensive development" in Sinai. How we went from comprehensive development to comprehensive ruination, or callous bigotry, I don't know.

Mind you, even the Bedouin, the true natives of Sinai, will have trouble complying with the law. They may be the descendants of tribes who have lived in Sinai since Moses walked the earth, but they will run into serious difficulties with these new regulations. Some of them only recently obtained official identity papers. Some were born to parents with no identity records. Some are married to citizens of other countries. And some acquired additional citizenships when they fled Sinai during the years of Israeli occupation.

So with one stroke of the pen, our cabinet has managed to antagonize everyone and wreck the future of hundreds of families. With one stroke of the pen, families that had successful businesses, families that kept spending out of their savings in the past two years just to stay afloat, are at once humiliated and bankrupted.

Who exactly is to gain?

The Bedouin are not going to gain. The foreigners who come to Sinai to feel at home in a cosmopolitan community will be scared off-. The property prices in Sinai are likely to go down the drain. The government, which claims interest in "comprehensive development" in Sinai, cannot possibly gain. No one is going to gain. It is a disaster all around.

The damage has been done; there's no two ways about it.

The best we can hope for right now is that the government of Hisham Qandil will do itself and us a favour and revoke these outrageous regulations as fast as possible. Perhaps then we'll lose only half of the investors instead of all. Perhaps then we'll avoid an avalanche of punitive lawsuits that will drown the country in a legal whirlpool of unspeakable dimensions. Perhaps then we'll restore to fellow Egyptians, mixed parenthood and multiple passports notwithstanding, some of the confidence they have lost.

 





Short link:

 

Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 4000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.
5



Lotfi
02-12-2012 10:29pm
0-
0+
Human Rights Violation
Don't believe this it is sure a very bad joke ; will say Israel do this with Palestinians, all of un condemned this & say that is criminal , and now we do as well but with Egyptians , they are almost 10 million abroad, stay Egyptians with also another nationality if we calculate 5 million have land home in Egypt to secure future for them and there children, they participate in Egypt economy when thy turn visiting Egypt one or more time by year, you imagine if you do this, you as well destroy a very important part of our identity, also will be as violation of liberty and personal life , and you will be in violation of human rights no body will accept this discrimination
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
4



tamer
22-11-2012 07:37pm
1-
5+
very smart not building more homes for people and make more people without home
Agree with u Khaled and I will add my dead buddy to u and a lot of buddy's of any buddy will dare to come and take me or my sun out of my home in ur dream mr prime minister u and any buddy els who think that we will fall without fight .if those who really shuld be looking for our interest not for making us suffer do ur job properly mr minister and for god sake look for people who really need help argent and don't be another government folwer doing what u been ordered without looking where u put ur feet .we have one word plz don't seek for more blood for egyptians without any reason ,
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
3



Ayman
22-11-2012 07:12am
18-
3+
Weak Argument
The article's argument against the decision is weak. Many countries forbid the sale of land to foreigners due to sovereignty and security issues. Anyone with a dual nationality can drop his non-egyptian nationality.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
2



khaled gomaa
21-11-2012 12:38pm
1-
25+
ourfuture kids future has been killed
i am one of the many who lives in sinai since 20 years having dual nationality, does that give any body the right to treat me less than a forigner.....the only thing that i have there is a house for me and my family, do you think that i will give it away that easy,let me tell you that nobody on earth will take my egyptian identity from me as well as my house.....that will be over my dead body.....mr prime minister think again carefully cause you do not know what you are facing.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
tamer
22-11-2012 07:47pm
0-
5+
tamam mr Khaled
I am with u all the way and we have to stand all together in sharm and all sharmers have to demand that together we r not less important than tahreer stands for our rights that is our rights we have to stand against them and the one who took that deciton I aproov that he have no glue about sanai or how we live here so I am with u in any way u will see for us to do to stope that stupidity .thanks
Maged
21-11-2012 10:07pm
0-
5+
Sinaï is our home and it will always be
I am totally agree with you Khaled. They should better think before to make such a thing !! And after all why an Egyptian who didn't want to loose his Egyptian nationality, has to loose his home. There is really much more important things to take care about than to take people' home and work....
1



Shari
21-11-2012 12:20pm
1-
13+
dual nationals in Sinai
Are our binational children from Egyptian fathers living and born in Sinai the new Palestinians of Sinai whose homes and houses can be taken from them??? Because of a new law that people with 2 nationalities can no longer own property in Sinai. The governement wants to treat its EGYPTIAN citizens like the Israelis treat the Palestinians but cry for our brothers in Gaza instead???
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
Hisham Akl
05-12-2012 12:39pm
0-
0+
The source of this decree?
Does anyone know where I can find the text of this deree/decision?!

© 2010 Ahram Online. Advertising