Liverpool defender Virgil Van Dijk accused Tottenham Hotspur striker Harry Kane of diving and Eric Lamela of exaggerating to get a penalty in Sunday's pulsating 2-2 Premier League draw at Anfield.
The visitors were awarded two penalties, one of which Kane scored with virtually the final kick of the game to earn his side a point.
Kane missed the other spot-kick after Loris Karius was adjudged to have brought him down.
But Dutchman Van Dijk, who was penalised for the second penalty, said neither should have been given.
"I think the first penalty was offside and I think it is a dive," Van Dijk said. "You see him (Kane) diving clearly and no-one is talking about that.
"There is a lot of discussion about whether it is offside, yes or no, but I think it was offside as well. The referee made his decision together with the linesman. It was good for us that it was saved."
Television sound recording of referee Jon Moss and his assistant revealed confusion about whether the ball had been accidentally played on to Kane by Liverpool's Dejan Lovren. Moss decided to award the kick even though he said he had "no idea" if the defender had touched the ball.
Van Dijk was equally critical of the second decision after Lamela collapsed theatrically under his challenge.
"For the second penalty, I see him coming and I try and hold my leg in, he just pulled his body in front of the ball and he goes down," Van Dijk said.
"The ref said play on and I was very disappointed that the linesman said otherwise. Unlucky I think.
"First of all it was offside and secondly he just put his body in front of me. I don't think that is a pen and the same with the first one."
The FA will decide whether to take retrospective action against Kane or Lamela, with both penalties likely to be reviewed by an independent panel.
Asked if he thought Kane should be punished for diving, Van Dijk added: "That is not something for me.
"I thought it was a dive - that is my opinion and the referee thought it was no offside and no dive and he gave a pen. Good for us that we saved it."
(For more sports news and updates, follow Ahram Online Sports on Twitter at @AO_Sports and on Facebook at AhramOnlineSports.)