Last Update 20:57
Tuesday, 12 November 2019

How to help Libya

There is a lot of know-how in the world about the challenges Libya will face in the future, and help must come from those with no second agendas

Lisa Anderson , Tuesday 12 Apr 2011
Share/Bookmark
Views: 6117
Share/Bookmark
Views: 6117

In September 1911, Italy invaded the last unoccupied North African provinces of the Ottoman Empire, sparking resistance that lasted 20 years, and ushering in a hundred years of ideologically driven, arrogant, and often vicious rule. It is fervently to be hoped that by the hundredth anniversary of the Italian invasion in September, this century of extravagant, vainglorious and deeply destructive politics will have drawn to a close.

It began with the Italian fascists, for whom imperialism was evidence of their belated Great Power status; they gave the province the name “Libya” — a term the ancient Greeks used for all of northern Africa — in an effort to evoke the glory of the ancient Roman Empire. Hundreds of thousands — perhaps as many as a million — Libyans died or fled their country during the brief Italian era, and those who survived were often forced off their land and into concentration camps, as the Italians attempted to establish settler colonies in the fertile areas along the coast.

The devastation did not end with the Italian defeat in World War II. After a brief interlude under a British and US-backed monarchy, in which the arrival of oil revenues in the late 1950s overwhelmed fragile state institutions, the fierce politics of the century returned with the regime that came to power in September 1969. Like the Italians, Qaddafi’s ambitions exceeded the territory he governed; for him, Libya was merely the epicentre of a world-wide revolution, and he, too, renamed the country to convey his aspirations, coining the word jamahiriyyah to express the radical novelty of his intentions. The Qaddafi regime, which seized land and property with almost as much impunity as the Italians, also never hesitated to use violence in the furtherance of its revolutionary goals, and many Libyan families have bitter memories of the last 40 years.

But it will not be easy to restore normalcy to a people brutalised by nearly a hundred years of ruthless and irresponsible rule. Although most Libyans continue to exhibit great generosity and good will, even after decades of abuse by their rulers, there is understandably very little trust of public institutions. Indeed, there is very little disciplined attachment to common economic interests and there are very few nationwide passions — even simple pleasures like football have been poisonously politicised.

Libyans are also understandably skittish about foreign entanglements and intrusions; they may need help to knit together stable institutions, built on mutual respect and confidence, but they are sceptical about the intentions of many of those who will offer to help, since they have too long been treated as a limitless funding source for hare-brained government schemes, crackpot private sector projects, and extraordinary garden-variety corruption.

So who might help, and what should they do? In the first instance, insofar as possible, advice should come from those who do not seek power or profit, which means not from foreign governments or international businesses and consulting companies. Fortunately, Libya does not need financial help, so its leaders can be very selective about where they seek advice and counsel. This means that there may be an opportunity, and perhaps an obligation, for international organisations, including the World Bank and UN bodies like UNESCO, UNICEF and the International Labour Organisation, to play an important role in Libya’s reconstruction. But perhaps more importantly, the non-official organisations of global civil society should be prepared to deploy their expertise. The hard-earned practical knowledge and pragmatic skill of the 70 former leaders of democratic countries represented in the Club of Madrid, which describes itself as seeking “to leverage the first-hand experience of its members to assist countries with critical elements of their democratic transition or consolidation,” could be put to good use, for example, as could the collective wisdom of organisations like Amnesty International, or Human Rights Watch.

There will be much work to do, from setting up a new police force to designing and implementing systems for judicial accountability, from convening a constitutional convention to re-establishing the Central Bank and reorganising the universities. But there is also much knowledge about these kinds of challenges in the world today, particularly in the global south where many countries have recent histories of conflict resolution and democratisation, and it could be put at the disposal of a new Libya. And if it were, we might just witness the beginning of a new, far more auspicious century for a country and people who certainly deserve better.

The writer is President of The American University in Cairo and an  expert on Libya

 

 

Short link:

 

Email
 
Name
 
Comment's
Title
 
Comment
Ahram Online welcomes readers' comments on all issues covered by the site, along with any criticisms and/or corrections. Readers are asked to limit their feedback to a maximum of 1000 characters (roughly 200 words). All comments/criticisms will, however, be subject to the following code
  • We will not publish comments which contain rude or abusive language, libelous statements, slander and personal attacks against any person/s.
  • We will not publish comments which contain racist remarks or any kind of racial or religious incitement against any group of people, in Egypt or outside it.
  • We welcome criticism of our reports and articles but we will not publish personal attacks, slander or fabrications directed against our reporters and contributing writers.
  • We reserve the right to correct, when at all possible, obvious errors in spelling and grammar. However, due to time and staffing constraints such corrections will not be made across the board or on a regular basis.
5



Elizabeth Godinez
23-10-2011 03:19am
0-
0+
Libya
the right to life is fundamentlal to other rights. YOU SHALL NOT KILL. Seek PEACE and pursue it. give time to end the divisions. protect all sides provide future stability consultative decision making for all come to agreements to prevent future bloodshed reconstruct revive economy remove effects of conflict rebuild trust seek reconciliation resolve cases search for TRUTH
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
4



freeasabird
14-04-2011 12:37am
0-
0+
How to help Libya
The author writes:"So who might help, and what should they do? In the first instance, insofar as possible, advice should come from those who do not seek power or profit, which means not from foreign governments or international businesses and consulting companies." With a country like Libya, rich in monetary terms, I don't see how anybody would approach helping Libya without thinking of a return on their investment. It is the Libyans' job to avoid being taken for a ride. The rebels just can't throw the old and start from scratch, they will need some in the current system to be able to sustain the country in these dire times. The rebels don't come across as quite promising I must say.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
3



freeasabird
13-04-2011 06:31pm
0-
0+
How to help Libya
The author writes:"So who might help, and what should they do? In the first instance, insofar as possible, advice should come from those who do not seek power or profit, which means not from foreign governments or international businesses and consulting companies." With a country like Libya, rich in monetary terms, I don't see how anybody would approach helping Libya without thinking of a return on their investment. It is the Libyans' job to avoid being taken for a ride. The rebels just can't throw the old and start from scratch, they will need some in the current system to be able to sustain the country in these dire times. The rebels don't come across as quite promising I must say.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
2



libyana
12-04-2011 08:03pm
0-
0+
excellent, but...
Great article, except you write that "advice should come from those who do not seek power or profit," and then name the World Bank. Um, last time I checked, the WB is VERY political. Also, since when are you an "expert" on Libya? I am Libyan, and at least once a week for years, I simply google "Libya" to see what is happening. I have not once come across your name. I think it's hilarious that everyone wants to call themselves pundits and experts on Libya. If you really are an expert, please post multiple links of what you have written.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
1



Rachida
12-04-2011 06:20pm
0-
0+
More Libyan voices please
This is a good article and I appreciate reading Ms. Anderson's erudite views, but I would appreciate hearing more from Libyan exiles in Egypt about what they want, rather than from more American or other Western experts, however expert and well-meaning. This is Libyans' nation, not anyone else's; there are a great many Libyan exiles in Egypt, both recent and longstanding, many of whom are highly educated and extremely knowledgeable. They know their history, their nation and what they want for it better than anybody, not just as an academic subject, but as a part of them; their wishes and aspirations for their country should be seen, heard and read before anybody else's, most especially in Arab nations' media.
Email
 
Name
 
Comment's Title
 
Comment
Latest

© 2010 Ahram Online.