EU corrects Ashton speech transcript after Israeli anger

APF and Ahram Online, Wednesday 21 Mar 2012

Israeli anger forces EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton to correct speech transcript which appeared to link French school shooting with suffering of children in Gaza

The European Union issued Tuesday a corrected version of a speech by its foreign policy chief, which had angered Israel because it appeared to link a French school shooting and Gaza.

The new transcript of Catherine Ashton's remarks mentions the situation of children in both Gaza and the southern Israeli town of Sderot after the first version only mentioned the Palestinian territory.

A video of her speech Monday showed she indeed mentioned Sderot, a town often hit by Palestinian rocket attacks.

After a day filled with criticism from Israeli officials including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Ashton denied that she ever compared the shooting at a Jewish school in Toulouse and the situation in the Middle East.

"I am really saddened by the distortion of my remarks," she told the EU parliament's foreign affairs committee. "I drew no parallel whatsoever between this tragedy and events elsewhere in the Middle East.

"I condemn unreservedly the terrible murders at the Ozar Hatorah school in Toulouse yesterday and extend my sympathies to the families and friends of the victims, to the people of France and the Jewish community."

In her speech at a youth event, Ashton paid tribute to children killed in "terrible circumstances" and listed a number of tragedies including unrest in Syria, last year's Norway massacre and the Toulouse shooting.

"When we see what is happening in Gaza and Sderot, in different parts of the world—we remember young people and children who lose their lives."

The phrase "and Sderot" had been missing from the first transcript of the speech given at the event in Brussels organised by the UN relief agency for Palestinian refugees (UNWRA).

The new text was released after a day of damage control, with her spokesman Michael Mann insisting her remarks were "grossly distorted," although he had not indicated at the time that she had talked about Sderot too.

Mann added that Ashton was making a "general remark" about violence against children around the world.

"She wanted to draw attention to the unfortunate fate of children around the world who lose their lives. Any indication or suggestion that there is a comparison or a parallel is incorrect," he told reporters.

EU officials contacted Israeli counterparts to clarify Ashton's remarks, an EU diplomat said.

Before the new transcript was released, Netanyahu, his defence minister and his foreign minister all criticised the remarks.

"What especially outrages me is the comparison between a targeted massacre of children and the surgical defensive actions of the IDF (Israel Defence Forces), intended to strike at terrorists using children as human shields," Netanyahu said

Israel killed 25 Palestinians in Gaza during four days of violence earlier this month. Palestinian rockets, which were fired in response to Israel's assassination of a resistance leader, killed no Israelis.

In late 2008 Israel launched a bombing campaign against Gaza codenamed Operation "Cast Lead." Between 27 December 2008 and 18 January 2009 Israel killed 1400 Palestinians, including 300 children and hundreds of other unarmed civilians.

"Much of the destruction was wanton and resulted from direct attacks on civilian objects as well as indiscriminate attacks that failed to distinguish between legitimate military targets and civilian objects," according to Amnesty International.

Short link: